I've more of less actually figured things out now.
Q: So Majesty, can we actually get all the rewards?
A: Unless some kind of pumpkin magic happens in the next 12 days, no and you can't even get all the s-chips if you're a functioning normal person.
Q: Why not? How many pumpkins can we get then?
A: The total event time is 13 days 17 hours. I'm almost certain that all pumpkins are only worth one pumpkin when harvested (I haven't encountered , king pumpkin and hundred day pumpkin which are the only special ones which I feel might buck this trend). Notably twin and triplet pumpkins do not count as multiple pumpkins and instead only 1 harvest. Thus, you have a total of 13*6+4 = 82 possible harvests. Since there's only 18 pumpkins in the field, that means you only have 82*18 = 1476 possible total harvest, though you can get more by items.
Q: Items? How you get those?
A: To start off, each pumpkin is technically worth slightly more than a pumpkin since they give you coins. The ones I've encountered all give 10 with the exception of twin giving 20 and triplet giving 30 and I have no idea if any other gives any more. With 120 coins you can buy 4 Small Haste Waters that give you another pumpkin, so technically they're worth slightly more than 1/12th of a pumpkin at worst (1/11th since it's an infinite geometric sequence but I refuse to bust out the hard mathematics here so I'm rounding). You use those coins to buy items in the shop. The male lead can also give you a gift of some items every hour that you actually have to collect every hour. Technically you can get 13*24+17=329 gifts, but I recommend you actually have a normal person sleep schedule and don't do that. From what I've seen, each gift is either 2 small haste waters, 1 haste water, or 1 growth water. Those are worth ~0.5, ~1, and ~0.5 of a pumpkin each, so assuming the probability distribution is equally weighted (approximately so from my observations), each gift gives you ~2/3 of a pumpkin if you want to factor that in.
Q: So then how should I spend my coins? What should I be buying?
A: Well nothing for the time being. There's nothing that forces you to use them immediately. I'm not sure if you can naturally get all 41 pumpkin types and all random events, or if some require you to use items. I reckon the hundred day pumpkin you definitely have to use the item for. Everything else is also best used as late as possible, since if you're going to fish for pumpkin types and events you best do it while you have the fewest number remaining and subsidize the rest with random probability. As for the growth items, well small haste water is just more flexible than haste water and cheaper per pumpkin (120 for 1 vs. 130 for 1), so it strictly dominates. Growth water seems to either give you twins or triplets (or apparently neither), but even assuming it can only give you those special types, it's only 15 extra coins on average but costs 200 while only reducing harvest time for 2 hours, so it's 185 net cost vs. 60 (2 small haste waters). In other words, for pumpkin efficiency it's small haste water all the way.
Q: So how many pumpkins can a reasonable person even get? What should I aim for?
A: To start off, the 1400 one for the highest s-chips requires you to be harvesting close to 5 times a day (around 4.75) and collecting around 15 gifts a day as well. I'd advise against that unless you're truly committed. On the other hand, the next bar for 1000 for s-chips only takes 4 harvests a day and just collecting a few gifts per day as buffer. It also lines up well with male lead harvest achievements. The most ideal harvest distribution is 100/100/100/700, with the 700 in the male lead whose Chip III you're most in need of. Talent mats you're going to naturally get while farming fragments/NXX case files/Lawsuit tokens, so if you can get Chip III through events and avoid the stamina for them that's most efficient. You only need 100 harvests to get the s-chips for each one, so the value works nicely. If you just want the badge, that won't even need 3 harvests a day and is very relaxed.
Q: Can you think of any good reason why miHoYo used the most user unfriendly system (NXX case files literally requiring you to collect on the dot every 4 hours with no rollover) for an event except they just made it worse (pumpkins are also every 4 hours but male lead gifts are literally every hour)?
A: You ask me who I ask I liked farming cabbages in Honkai way better that was way more chill bring it back.
Link to the Master Guide List


