Nahida tests included R5 Widsith with 69.2 CR / 158 CD EM, EM and CR Total 567 EM no bonus, R5 Widsith with 70.3 CR / 158 CD EM, Dendro and CR Total 421 no bonus
R5 Mappa Mare 62.2 CR / 121.5 CD EM, EM and CR Total EM 696, R5 Mappa Mare 63.3 CR / 121.5 CD EM, Dendro and CR Total EM 549
R5 Magic Guide 62.2 CR / 121.5 CD EM, EM and CR Total EM 774, R5 Magic Guide 63.3 CR / 121.5 CD EM, Dendro and CR Total EM 627
All tests were done with full Deepwood Memories set on one member.
The team included Barbara, Yae Miko and Fischl which is the most common team I use for Nahida. I had to switch Barbara from the Thrilling Tales of the Dragon to the Prototype Amber because Nahida's elemental skill was affected by the attack bonus. The variability was difficult to control, however it adds a decent damage to Nahida's attack.
The Perpetual Mechanical Array first phase was the enemy. This includes all resistance and I did not test its second phase.
Results
No other bonuses were applied and I did not activate Nahida's elemental burst.
The Widsith does not snapshot, which means the bonus will fall off even if the skill is applied with the bonus active. This means the bonus is only good for 10 seconds no matter what. This was a huge disappointment.
Widsith EM, Dendro CR
EM Bonus 37,690
Dendro bonus 32,456
Attack bonus 25,974
No bonus 21,314
Widsith EM, EM and CR
EM Bonus 33.982
Dendro Bonus 32,382
Attack bonus 23,684
No bonus 19,834
Mappa Mare EM, Dendro C*
**% bonus 25,335
Mappa Mare EM, EM C*
**% bonus 24,081
Magic Guide EM, Dendro CR
24% bonus 25,539
No bonus 22,854
Magic Guide EM, EM CR
24% bonus 24,195
No bonus 21,238
Everything above is objective data. Everything below is my opinion.
The Widsith has the highest damage when the bonus is applied by a giant margin, however it does not snapshot limiting the highest damage to 10 seconds. The Magic Guide and Mappa Mare bonuses can be maintained 100%. The Widsith has the highest potential if the EM bonus is applied, however the lowest if the attack bonus is applied. I recommend the Widsith if someone wants to see ridiculously high numbers and I am curious how high that 37,690 would be if applied to the second phase of The Perpetual Mechanical Array which has almost 0 resistance. Maybe almost 50,000.
The Mappa Mare has the most consistent damage by far and I am not sure why this is. Just having Nahida on the field for a second here and a second there obtains the full 32% bonus. I did not use the elemental burst for this test, however I know from my Abyss runs casting the elemental skill and burst is enough to achieve 100% bonus.
The Magic Guide was the biggest surprise with damage in the range of 4-star weapons. However, highest damage was difficult to obtain and only achieved about 50% of the time. Strange because water and electric attacks were constantly present. This weapon produced the second highest results for 1 hit damage, however I am sure the overall damage from the Mappa Mare will be higher in the end. I highly recommend the Magic Guide for anyone looking for a F2P or less expensive option. It is too good be called a 3-star weapon.
Conclusion
In my opinion, The Widsith is best for incredible damage and probably the highest if EM bonus is rolled frequently.
The Mappa Mare is my favorite for Nahida because of its consistent damage. I am not a fan of variable damage.
Magic Guide is the best low-cost option and competes with 4-star weapons. Obtaining the 24% bonus produces damage about the same level as The Widsith which is impressive.

