"Chotto Matte Majesty, didn't you just post this?"
If that's what you're thinking, no you aren't blind and no you aren't hallucinating. For a multitude of reasons, I'm going to posting some things twice for some time going forward. You can treat it as an experiment for data collection for experiments in the future. If you're wondering if there's going to be any differences, well I'm too lazy post pictures a second time so that's the only thing that'll change between them.
_________________________________________________________________________
Well, only one new weapon this patch. miHoYo can you decide if you guys are going to try to make generalist weapons or actually want to make specialist weapons and actually make them for every character, b/c this weird random swapping every so often is not what I would call healthy for game progression.
Calamity Queller
Simply put, it’s a stat-stick. A braindead stat-stick compared to the other options, to be exact. A braindead stat-stick that’s better than the existing options when off-field, to be more exact.
Let’s take the comparison targets: Jade-Winged/Homa/Vortex, since those are all stat-stick weapons as opposed to the ER 5* options. Well, Jade-Winged is only slightly better at max stacks (more ATK%, DMG% has slightly better coverage) if both are on field, though Jade-Winged requires you to stack it manually and swap in every 6s to maintain stacks as opposed to Calamity literally being press 1 button every 20s. And Calamity is a bigger stat-stick off-field. Calamity’s also going to be a larger stat-stick than Homa assuming average HP (~20,000) and also a bigger stat-stick off-field even when below half HP. Both Jade-Winged and Homa help with the stat distribution given their substats, though that’s less of an issue at higher investments. Calamity won’t out stat-stick Vortex assuming you have a shield and stack even when off-field, but it also has DMG% and since both give lots of ATK%, Calamity’s high base ATK is almost guaranteed to outscale Vortex in terms of return.
In other words, if the character stays off-field for their primary damage (AKA if they don’t snapshot), then this weapon just gives you the most stats. If they don’t stay off-field for their primary damage, to be honest you still might consider using Calamity anyways. It’s an alternative lazy option compared to Homa since all you need to do is press E every 20s, and depending on your stat distribution it’ll be more effective.
As for specific character users:
Hu Tao: Needs HP and stays below half HP, just use Homa.
Raiden Shogun: Well, her E doesn’t snapshot so it could make use of Calamity’s affix. That being said, if you’re using Raiden as an E bot that’s not exactly good mileage, and if you do use her burst then Lightning and even the other stacking stat-sticks will serve you better for damage.
Rosaria: Her burst snapshots, so you wouldn’t get full benefit from Calamity. Not to mention, if you’re using her as support, she wants crit rate. That being said, unless you want to perfectly time her E swaps to keep up Jade-Winged stacks, you can just run Calamity and be lazy. It’s not like you particularly need ER to use one of the ER weapons, especially if you’re with a second Cryo.
Shenhe: Unfortunately her burst field does snapshot, so she doesn’t get maximum use of the weapon. That being said, Icy Quill AKA the vast majority of her damage contribution in relevant parties is completely dynamic, so this weapon by far gets maximum value for enhancing her damage there.
Thoma: His burst doesn’t snapshot and is also most of his damage, so he can actually make full use of Calamity’s affix. That being said, if you’re using Thoma you kind of want his shield not to break and you kind of need ER even with C4, so you’ll probably find Homa/Lightning more comfortable on him.
Xiangling: Her skill and burst both snapshot, so you don’t get full value there. Not to mention, with how unreliable Guoba is hitting enemies and generating particles, she’ll almost certainly need ER. Well, if you’re okay on that then you can either use this or Homa for max laziness.
Xiao: Repeat after me: miHoYo hates Xiao.
Yun Jin: Yeah no ATK% is pretty much useless on her and her buff doesn’t scale off her own DMG%, so Calamity (and all the stat stick weapons) are pretty much useless on her so just use an ER weapon.
Zhongli: Also needs HP so Homa as well. If you’re using him for resonance damage, well his steles snapshot and then you’d be swapping onto him often so maintaining Vortex stacks wouldn’t be extra work and you’d just get more stats from it.
Verdict: If you need a general offensive stat-stick polearm and especially if you’re lazy af, then it’s either this or Homa, Homa being more on the defensive and specific use side but also needing less stat investment, while Calamity being the more generally effective offensive weapon.
For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.


