First of all, if you're an Otto hater, I apologize for gracing your timeline about him. Second of all, I am also totally unapologetic because well this is about him. You see I have a love-hate relationship with the man called Otto Apocalypse. I have liked countless people who are either villains or have done villainous acts (because you can be a nice guy but inevitably do something that's not something majority would accept) in fiction because I find the dark side of humanity interesting. So, you can't really hold it against me. But you know, a villain is great when they make you hate them so much, they'd be lingering on the back of your mind, forever stuck as THAT one villain.
Note: While there are certain circumstances that's not completely by Otto, it created a series of unfortunate events. Also, this is SPOILER-HEAVY for those that wants to have the Honkai Experience.





Act I. Schick****9;s Rule

This is it where it all started. You see, Schicksal was what the world needed. In a world where Honkai Beasts exist to create destruction and havoc, you needed saviors and this was the leading organization against them (because yes 3 Flame-Chasers from Previous Era is not enough to stop Honkai worldwide. I mean look at what happened in their civilization.)

GOOD:
⎆ Otto found the cure for the Black Death thereby allowing Eleanor to live, be a Valkyrie and become Abyss Flower's first wielder.
⎆ Otto helped Kallen to be a rogue-extraordinaire. Steal from the rich (in this case Schicksal) and give them to the poor.
⎆ Otto helped Kallen defeat a Honkai Beast-turned Eleanor (which is kind of sad to see how quick he is to discard Eleanor who actually had sentience just that she really hated Kallen).
⎆ Otto allows Kallen to leave with the Black Box.
⎆ Otto sent Oath of Judah to Kallen when she sent him a letter.
BAD:
⎆ Otto experimented on humans during the Black Death to find its cure.
⎆ Otto is privy to the knowledge that Schicksal kidnap children for the experiments.
⎆ Otto continued to study Eleanor's remains to create a serum that would create stronger Valkyries which inevitably caused the death of countless subjects.

It's easy to see how Otto's worth is very much dependent on Kallen's happiness.


I have to pour a little connection here. You see, Otto saved Eleanor's life which made Eleanor entirely dedicated to Otto. Meanwhile, Kallen is Otto's special person, making her bitter towards Kallen. Admiration can truly twist a person.

The Death of the Holy Maid

GOOD: Otto helped the Schicksal Eradication Society and overturned its ruling party. In the later years, created a decent livelihood for Schicksal Personnel as seen from the opinions during the latest arc.
BAD: Otto released Honkai Beasts during Kallen's execution.
Yes, her execution is something Kallen did not deserve. But it was her own choice. If you've watched Thus Spoke Apocalypse, Kallen had the power to escape but she didn't. She decided to save the townspeople who were there to watch her, Schick****9;s strongest Valkyrie, to die. Many more people wouldn't had to needlessly die if it weren't for Otto releasing Honkai Beasts. Not only her death was in his hands (even if it was a Honkai Beast that killed her). He is responsible for the deaths of the lives in that area. On another note, we also blame Risa Apocalypse for instigating Otto to do this. She died anyway.

Act II. The 500-year Journey
The Creation of Anti-Entropy

GOOD:
⎆ Welt Joyce's transfer to The Royal Institute 42 allowed him to become acquainted with Einstein and Tesla.
⎆ Schick****9;s North American Branch defects and becomes Anti-Entropy.
⎆ Welt Yang inherits the Core and becomes the Herrscher of Reason as well as the second Herrscher to fight for humanity.
⎆ Einstein’s and Tesla’s aging were slowed down allowing them to further help the world and halt Otto's plans if it were ever to harm humanity.
BAD:
⎆ Welt Joyce lost his freedom, turned into a lab rat so that humanity could learn more about Herrschers.
⎆ Reanna Brigantia was turned into an android.
⎆ Babylon Labs started the human experimentation.
⎆ Otto destroyed Edison’s experiment causing the Honkai power reactor to explode.
⎆ Otto controls Reanna to kill Elias, Welt Yang's father.
⎆ Edison sacrifices herself to prevent the Honkai sphere from falling to New York.
⎆ Otto deployed a Honkai Fissile Bomb to New York but was detonated early and the blast was negated by Reanna who died in the process and by Joyce, who was on the brink of death.
⎆ Otto almost caused a nuclear war between US and USSR,
⎆ In a sense, Valkyries had to view Anti-Entropy as enemies.

GOOD:
⎆ Otto saved Li Sushang's life.
⎆ Otto creates Theresa (World's No. 1 Cutie) and Amber.
⎆ Cecilia and Siegfried became a couple.

BAD:
⎆ Otto, not only made Theresa, but multiple clones from Kallen and the Honkai Beast Vishnu's genes, made them undergo a series of test and murder each other to see which is fit for survival. You'd most likely be in denial but Otto did care for Theresa to some extent.
⎆ Otto only allowed Siegfried to be with Cecilia after completing tasks for him. Also, Otto was interested what would happen if a Kaslana and a Schariac (especially Cecilia having the purifying blood most likely due to the experimentation) gene combine. Yeah, definitely not a part of his experiments.
⎆ To be fair, waking up in a a completely different era would be shocking.
The Second Eruption

GOOD:
⎆ Well, at least Otto mobilized Valkyries (who unfortunately had to die because of the Eruption).
⎆ The trip to the moon so that Welt could deal with Sirin had allowed for them to acquire Soulium data entries regarding the Previous Era. This allowed the Kevin stigmata interact with Siegfried and awaken his dormant Honkai genes as part of the Kaslana lineage.
⎆ Otto did clean up Siberia with the use of 4th Divine Key (which was basically his fault).
BAD:
⎆ Sirin awakens as the Herrscher of Void as a result of the hatred and trauma brought upon from being experimented and the death of her friends. Also creates 4 Pseudo-Herrschers that wreaked havoc.
⎆ A lot of Valkyries and innocent people died. Valkyries Shub-****urath, Salome Jokanaan, Patricia Highsmith, and Cheng Lixue---all four members of Snow Wolf Squad, Cecilia's squad, died.
⎆ Otto prevented Welt Yang from finishing Sirin which allowed her to gain more powers granted by the Will of Honkai.
⎆ Fu Hua had to unleash Edge of Taixuan at the cost of her memories to suppress Sirin.
⎆ Otto ordered for Honkai Fissile Bombs to be deployed in the area to cover up the events.
⎆ Cecilia, who's supposed to be on leave, had to fight once again. She dies sacrificing herself later on.
⎆ Otto used Mimicry of Fenghuang Down and alters Theresa’s memories of the war, thereby removing the existence of the Anti-Entropy aiding them.
⎆ Siegfried has to deal with his Honkai genes.

Act III. Where It All Ends and Begins

Unhinged right there.

Pretty unapologetic, actually.
GOOD:
⎆ In his 500-year rule as the Overseer, provided Schicksal the equipment to be able to defeat Honkai.
⎆ K-423, our precious protagonist, is born.
⎆ In a way, he has become Durandal's guardian.
⎆ St. Freya was allowed to operate and funded by Schicksal with Theresa as its principal.
⎆ Otto fixes Fu Hua's body, giving birth to the 8th Herrscher, that in a way was not fully on the side of Honkai, allowing Fu Hua to control the 8th's powers to an extent.
⎆ The power of friendship created more Herrschers that fight for humanity, in a way.
⎆ Otto resigns, hands over Schicksal to Theresa and made everyone (not World Serpent) join hands to defeat him.
BAD:
⎆ K-423 was created so Otto can control a Herrscher.
⎆ The real Kiana, Bianka, was kept by Otto. In a sense, he's the reason why Bianka became an orphan.
⎆ Bianka, at age 12, was sent to the Sea of Quanta along with Rita. (I know this is a war and all but it's sad to think that we have to send 12-year olds to shoulder the responsibility of saving humanity.)
⎆ More experiments.
⎆ Ana Schariac became a Valkyrie at age 12. (Once again an example of a child soldier. Especially one that bears the Schariac name.)
⎆ Murata Himeko sacrifices herself to bring back Kiana. (While Himeko's days were already numbered, she could have had at least a year to spend it with her loved ones.) This event forces Kiana to separate from those she loved and had to live in guilt.
⎆ Otto shoots Fu Hua.
⎆ Kiana having the Kaslana lineage as part of her makes her as sacrificial as her predecessors that may ultimately lead to her doom. Mei wanting to save Kiana had to align herself with World Serpent, which also basically have a really not-so-good but kinda understandable plan against the Honkai.

But you know what makes him a great villain?

He is a man of focus, commitment, and sheer, f****** will.
It's really crazy to do all this for one dead woman.
One that had accepted her death and saw it as an act of defiance against the organization that had used her for its crusades.
On another hand, you'd agree with how it was unfair for someone as great and valiant as Kallen to die because a council of old men was threatened because of her.
At this point, you'd have to applaud him for his dedication. It's evil to the core. As Otto, himself, said:
"Human emotions... they're raw desires without any regard for the consequences. But generally the heroes restrain their emotion with reason, but the villains let their emotions run wild. As for reasonable villains, they're no more than calculating, predictable machines. Lesser beings than men."
To which Void Archives reply:
"... Is it so? The way I see it, you're a perfect example of reasonable villains."
Otto answers him once again:
"I won't deny it. Rather, I know very well I'm just as unworthy as any of them. Like I said... we choose to believe that our loved ones would live forever. And I'm just a fool dominated by this desperate wish who leaves no stone unturned trying to realize it."
He, too, has acknowledged that he was a fool and Chapter 27: Dusk of the Fool is basically a criticism of Otto Apocalypse through the conversation between himself and Void Archives. Otto was really just an unfortunate man, who found his reason to live through Kallen. A reason so strong, desperation turned into obsession. It's what's frightening about Otto, he very much knows what he was doing. He has a long line of corpses at his feet, blood on his hands all for a selfish wish.

This is just a summary of why Otto is THAT villain. The fact that many so hate him and the fact that there are people who respected him but nonetheless knew his actions were wrong. He is not that world's main antagonist, but he is the story's main antagonist. The story moved because of the plans he orchestrated that rooted 500 years ago. Honkai is humanity's enemy but he surely had made his impact on the world.

tl;dr:
Hate him or love him, Otto's contributions to the world is a fact that cannot be erased. Without Otto, there would be no K423 and Theresa. Both important characters in the story. Without K423, countless lives would have been taken in Heliopolis due to World Serpent. Without Theresa, there would be no St. Freya. Himeko would not become a teacher and saved K423, Mei, and Bronya's lives.
Otto is an absolute perverse and abhorrent man. Everything that he did cannot be excused. But even so Otto Apocalypse, in my opinion, is not just a simp meme. One misconception about him is because he was a "simp." Kallen was the first person to believe in him. Platonic or romantic, we can see it either way. They were best friends. He didn't force Kallen to love him nor did he chain her to his side. He neglected all consequences all to bring back the only person who made him feel worthy, the one who has been sentenced to death despite fighting for the people.
He believed in the power of love and bonds, placing all his bets that K423 will overcome the Herrscher. But that belief, twisted him to go beyond---to become an extremely manipulative, dedicated, and inhumanely cruel individual. Otto created better equipment to fight against the Honkai, had manipulated events to weaponize the Herrscher of the Void later on becoming Herrscher of Flamescion to fight for humanity and united the two largest anti-Honkai organizations---World Serpent and Schicksal. He has Theresa and the Anti-Entropy to combine efforts in order to stop him and prove to him that they can save the world. Laughably all a side effect for his crusade to revive Kallen. But at the end of the day, he still believed that Kallen could save the world, the dream she had during their childhood, and everyone else who fight against the Honkai are all Kallen's legacy.

I'd probably make a video that covers more on history and background which means going back to all stories that involve him to justify how much effort miHoYo had placed in his character.


