Post Details Page

[V1.4 Guide] 1.4 New Weapon Analysis

UID: 600014775


I told you guys I'd write a serious one later, didn't I?


In any case, I don't normally write guides on weapons, since if you've read my previous guides you'll know I extremely, highly discourage the vast majority of the population from pulling on those banners since you're liable to completely screw yourself over by RNG.  However, miHoYo events are literally "read and you can do them" and since I've already covered how to do that in almost every guide, not much use in making those.  Rosaria's also not in another 3 weeks, so I can't convert my normal short rundown into a Xiao-style essay atm. So yeah, that being said, might as well let you know what's at the bottom of the bridge before you light yourself on fire and jump off the bridge without a bungee to know what you're getting yourself into.  

There are 5 new weapons this patch, and I'll cover them starting from the new 5*.




Elegy of the End


According to the Genshin Impact wiki, at R5 the first blue number is 120 and the other two are 200 and 40%.  


Equipment Comparison

Since Elegy's a damage-increasing support weapon, both comparisons between similar support weapons and other bows are necessary.  We'll start across support weapons.


There's two other support weapons that increase damage directly.  The first is Thrilling tales of dragon slayer.  It's a 3* and if you even play this game you'll probably have a billion copies of this at R5.  At R5 it's a 48% atk% increase for 10s to one party member every 20s.  It's easier to use and gives more attack than Elegy, but conversely has a slightly shorter duration, isn't full party coverage, and doesn't give EM.

That aside, since Elegy is a 5* and Dragon Slayer is a 3*, for most people it's R1 vs. R5 and thus a tradeoff between 100 EM and half of atk%.  At R5 vs. R5 the atk% is pretty negligible, so it's literally the extra EM you're considering when using it over Dragon Slayer.  Unlike Dragon Slayer, Elegy is also more annoying to stack so it's more annoying to use.  However, if you use Dragon Slayer even if it's level 90 that character is not doing any damage.  Since Elegy is higher base attack and has helps recharge burst and is team-wide, both the user and the remaining team members will do more damage as well.  Thus, if your supports do no damage or you only care about Main DPS or you're poor or don't need EM, no reason to get this over just running Dragon Slayer.  If the rest of your team does damage and you care about EM on them as well or you're a whale, Elegy will be better.


The other comparison is between Elegy and Gravestone.  Since both are 5* unless you got cursed on Homa banner both of them will be relatively equal refinement.  Gravestone gives the entire party 80% atk% for 12s with a 30s cd when the user hits an enemy below 30% hp.  Thus, both weapons give entire party coverage.  Elegy obviously has higher uptime.  There's one more important distinction.  When fighting groups including trash mobs, then Gravestone is essentially just a 40% uptime support weapon.  If there are no adds, then Gravestone is strictly a low enemy hp burst weapon since there are no easy trigger enemies.

Gravestone gives more attack and is easier to proc when conditions exist, but doesn't give EM, is much shorter uptime and dependent on enemy composition.  The gravestone user itself will also do more damage due to offensive substat/affix, unless they're burst dependent in which case if they can't keep their burst 100% uptime Elegy's ER would be relevant.  Thus, if you're fighting enemies which you can keep the passive up or you don't need EM or need concentrated stat increase to burst, then no reason to run Elegy over Gravestone.  If you need EM or want higher coverage increase or enemy conditions makes Gravestone's 30% requirement less effective, then Elegy will be better.


Moving onto comparison between bows, do not run this weapon as DPS against other 5*'s.  At best, the passive 120 EM + the 200 EM will give you slightly more than 52% increased damage on amp reactions with at best 60% uptime on the extra 200; otherwise it will only slightly less than a 22% increase.  It's equally as poor on damage reactions; with the buff active you electro-charged will do 124% more damage, which is ~3500 extra damage at level 90, not exactly the greatest increase.  If your charged attacks are more than 50% of your total damage, Amos will give you greater output and otherwise, Skyward Harp as a stat stick is better.  If you're low on energy and need burst, you're better off just swapping up team composition with an on-element support.  As for supporting, it doesn't generate as much energy as either Favonius or Sacrificial bow for your team and is lower ER than Favonius even on the user, so if you're using the bow, the ER is secondary to the support buff.  


Character Use


Running the table here:


Amber:  Should be able to proc the buff on every burst unless you get trolled by wonky hitboxes, can't proc it otherwise since Baron Bunny literally is one instance of damage.  Doesn't benefit much from the EM either since burst is also bound to wipe out elements and be the application element over the trigger, though if you have C2 and want to use Baron Bunny as a bomb instead of a lure, you will have a ~450% amp possible so it's okay.  Overall, an okay user since with a 12s burst you'll have high uptime on proccing and can mildly make use of the EM.

Diona: Tap e only adds 1 stack, Held e adds 2 stacks.  Burst adds one stack per tick since every tick is once every 2s.  If you're using Diona to do dmg you're trolling so the EM isn't particularly relevant for her.  Without Sacrificial Bow to reset her e, you're either going to have to hold your e until buff cd is ready or use tap e's to build stacks, both of which are annoying.  That being said, her C6 can already add 200 EM, so this bow would be a 400EM support in burst and the cd of the buff lines up with her burst cd.  Thus, if you're setting up for next level melt support nuke on a Pyro, it'd be great despite the hassle otherwise it's not worth using on her.

Fischl: Fischl's not triggering too many electro-charged reactions since by ICD oz will only trigger a reaction every 2-3s or so, so the EM is not very useful for her.  That being said, since oz is always attacking you can turn off your brain in terms of proccing this buff since it'll always come up when it's ready due to oz constantly attacking.  I'm not sure if A2 and C6 count as elemental skill/burst damage, but worse case it takes 4s for the buff to come up, but you don't really have to manage it.  ER might be a waste though since Fischl is inherently high energy generation.  Overall, she's an okay user for lazy application of buff.

Ganyu: I'd question why you are using Ganyu as a support, but if you are fighting larger groups of enemies then this bow is actually very good on her as a support.  Ganyu's burst is 100% uptime and 100% coverage up to a point.  Icicles will only target enemies at most once every 5th icicle, but enemies can get hit by random drops and this is per target so if there are 5+ enemies, all icicles home.  That and 3 icicles fall per second, which is longer than the buff internal cd for stacking.  At best the buff stacks almost instantly and at worst it'll take a few seconds.  Ganyu icicles are also not a bad melt target, since they all apply weak cryo and have decently good ratios, so as long as your pyro application is sufficient all of them will melt, so the EM is actually okay useful on her.  Thus, this bow is pretty good on her if you're using her as a damage support against larger groups of enemies, otherwise it's pretty average.

Tartaglia: Okay, so I have 0 idea if his auto-attacks in his melee form work (probably not and only his riptide does).  If they don't, it's literally absolute garbage but if they do, it'd be mildly usable in an electro-charged build but not in a vaporize one, since you're not stacking the buff and applying pyro to amp your burst simultaneously.  Just use Harp and go vaporize instead.  

Venti: If they intended this to be his signature weapon, they kinda screwed up.  Since anemo can only swirl and swirl does 0 damage, the EM is useless on him.  Also, while he might have incredibly high coverage and ease of use on the buff due to his burst stacking it almost immediately, especially against groups, he's sacking his own damage to do so.  Since Venti's ascension stat is ER and his A2 already gives an energy refund, the substat feels redundant and overkill in most situations.  If you want to provide EM+atk%+Viridescent Debuff, then a Sucrose with Dragon Slayer pretty much does the same thing and is easier to trigger outside of not buffing your party's atk%.  Honestly, it's not a bad weapon on him; it's pretty good but there's an easier way to get the same job done and you're better off just running Harp on him to kill things faster as a support instead of proccing this support buff.  


Verdict

Honestly, just use Thrilling Tales of Dragon Slayers, it pretty much does the same stuff unless you can really use that EM and your entire party does damage.  Since only 1 person is proccing any particular reaction, even if your entire party is getting the EM buff only 1 character is really making use of it.  And it's not that good as a DPS weapon unlike WGS which you can throw onto anyone as a stat stick outside of a support weapon.  Thus, unless you really, really, seriously really know what you're doing with this weapon and what you're going to use it for, skip and just pull on a banner with 2 DPS 5*'s weapons instead since that requires way fewer conditions and brain usage.




Alley Hunter

MIA until next banner, I'll come to update it then I guess (Or not, I'm at 19k characters right now so I'll have to make a part 2 LOL)


Edit: Part "2" if you can call it that here



Windblume Ode


Literally a free R5 weapon, why do you need a guide on whether or not to get this?  Just max refine and max enhance this during the bonus exp event period and throw it on whoever you need a bow for damage on.




Wine and Song


According to the Genshin Impact wiki, at R5 the first blue number is 22% and the second one is 40%.  


Equipment Comparison

Since Drunk Alcoholic Book is a 4* weapon, wouldn't make sense to compare it to 5* weapons since if you have a 5* weapon, you'll just use the 5* weapon.  W&S definitely is meant to be a DPS weapon and a main DPS weapon at that.  You don't really sprint on supports and 5s of an atk% increase isn't long enough for any supports that do damage off-field, not to mention if you were to use it as a swap support weapon you'd have to swap, sprint, then use skill as opposed to insta-bursting on swap.  You're better off just using Widsith for that.  Even if the substat is ER, its affix provides no supporting ability such as Favonius or Sacrificial.  

Crossing all of those out leaves us with Solar Pearl, Royal, Blackcliff, and Mappa Mare.  1 atk ~ 0.75 dmg due to feather taking up around 25% of your flat attack with no percentage bonuses, so you can approximate W&S as a 30% dmg increase give or take.  Solar is a 40% damage increase on everything minus charged attacks, so if charged attacks make up less than 25% of your damage composition and you don't need the ER for your burst/burst isn't an important part of your damage, it's better.  Royal's better the less optimized your stats are since it's refinement is worth the most at 0% crit and decreases with any other crit sources you have, but it's literally functionally a crit vs. atk% and ER tradeoff between the two which Royal normally loses.  Blackcliff is better if you consistently maintain stacks or don't need ER otherwise it's worse.  Mappa functionally gives similar damage and it's literally just an EM vs. ER tradeoff.  This is assuming you can maintain the passive atk% increase all the time, as the stamina consumption passive only gives you 1 extra dash approximately every 4.5 dashes and doesn't work for general exploration since you probably aren't hitting an enemy every 5s.  Thus, there's a very specific set of circumstances where this weapon would be meaningfully better than something that doesn't already exist.


Character Use


Running the Table with Catalyst Users:

Barbara: Please uninstall if you run her as main DPS.  That being said, the stamina reduction affix gets diluted by her own, her entire build is around vaporizing her charged attacks and her burst doesn't do damage, so literally just run Mappa instead over this if you want to play this meme.

Klee:  Charged attacks are a large part of her damage and she can't keep her auto-attack increase up due to long cds and she definitely does not innately generate energy well even with that charged attack passive.  While Klee also wants to amp react, she's a lot busier compared to Barbara since she literally has 20 billion different things hitting at once which makes it more difficult to amp the right ones.  Thus, you're okay running W&S over Solar/Mappa on Klee, but the difference most likely won't be meaningful, especially since Klee's charged attacks are free and thus the stamina reduction won't be useful there.  

Lisa: Since Lisa's built around spamming charged attacks and doesn't have a stamina removal passive, the reduction would actually be mildly useful here, not to mention you need to sprint to cancel delay on her held e and charge attacks which leave you as a sitting duck already.  You do also need some amount of energy recharge even if you're using Thundering Fury to maintain your ult with 100% uptime.  Lisa also gets EM from her ascension stat and electro, making Mappa's substat more diluted and less useful.  Overall, probably one of the better users for W&S, still not a super relevant difference.

Mona: W&S is awkward because it actually feels decent to use on C6 Mona since every time you dodge you proceed to stay in torrent for 2s to trigger A2 explosion puppet and the 120% damage increase on your next charged attack makes up for the lost damage in the dashing downtime.  On the other hand, if you have C6 Mona you have better options than W&S.  Mona does get a slight amount of offensive stats from the ER conversion and really does need her burst to do damage and can't regenerate it naturally herself.  Also one of the better users for W&S but also not too relevant a difference.

Ningguang: Does use charged a lot due to the stamina canceling passive, but the rest of her kit is a large part of her damage composition as well.  EM is useless because crystallize shields are made of paper.  Doesn't really need ER because you pretty much have to go double geo team for the resonance and thus energy not really an issue.  Nothing is canceled by sprint so to keep up the passive you have to manually insert that into the gameplay loop.  Fine but no major difference in effectiveness.

Sucrose: Please also uninstall if you run her as main DPS.  That aside, Sucrose auto's do 0 damage but EM is useless on her since she can only swirl and she definitely needs the ER to get her burst up.  All 3 are equally not very useful on her and pretty much interchangeable.  


Verdict

Setting aside conditional situations where Royal/Blackcliff might be better, for general use it would pretty much perform the same as Pearl or Mappa.  There's pretty much no reason to get this if you already have one or the other, unless you are really going to be able to make use of that stamina reduction and you really need that specific amount of ER.  


The Alley Flash


According to the Genshin Impact wiki, at R5 the blue number is 24%.


Equipment Comparison

0 support ability, so cross that out.  Substat might as well not exist since it's literally so low and EM.  Assuming you take 0 damage and thus the affix is always active, it's slightly better than a max stacked Rancour on pure elemental dealers, worse than Lion's Roar against elemental-infused enemies, pretty much the same as max stacked Iron Sting, better than the Flute if you don't auto much, and better than Black Sword if less than 60% of your damage if from autos and you amp/already have good crit distribution.  Same situational effectiveness compared to Blackcliff/Royal as W&S has.  In other words, doesn't do much over other weapon choices for main DPS.  On the other hand, the 24% damage increase will work off-field for abilities, which none of those swords can do.  It's not the greatest increase, but it's better than nothing.  That is, unless your off-field damage is from elemental skills, in which case Festering Desire is just strictly better.


Character Use


Running the Table with Sword Users:

Albedo: Just run Festering Desire or Harbinger of Dawn instead of this garbage on him, it'll literally make his elemental skill do more damage and EM is useless on him since he's geo.

Bennett: For support Bennett, it's the same evaluation as Skyward Blade vs Aquila Favonius; if you can maintain his ult without the ER weapon, then just use the high base attack weapon otherwise use the ER weapon and it's the same with this weapon vs a 4* ER weapon.  Also usable on main DPS Bennet since he can amp but you might as well just go Sting since you're almost certainly getting hit and healing in your ult and they pretty much give the same damage.  

Jean: If you're going main DPS, better to go Flute or Rancour, if you want nukes on e just go Festering and if you want better healing just run an ER weapon so your burst comes up faster.  EM is useless on her anyways since she can only swirl.

Kaeya: Okay on burst-slave Kaeya, since you can reverse melt on him to make use of the EM and get the dmg increase, but only if you can keep the ult up otherwise without ER which shouldn't be too hard considering his kit.  If you're going main DPS, Sting does the same job.

Keqing: You definitely don't use this over Lion's Roar or Black Sword on main DPS.  Guess it's okay if you're just using her as an e and burst slave.

Qiqi: Alright nice try, your skills don't do damage anyways and you literally need an ER weapon in order to remotely have any meaningful usage of your burst.

Traveler: EM is useless on both types.  Okay if you're just swapping them in to use e and burst, otherwise as main DPS just use something else.

Xingqiu: Good for off-field since the dmg increase will always be up, though Xingqiu is normally the applier and not the trigger for reactions so the EM will probably be wasted.  For main DPS literally Sting still exists.  Also good luck keeping that burst up without ER anywhere.


Verdict

Not much differentiation or use over other weapons as a Main DPS weapon, but is better than them as an off-fielder weapon but only if both e and burst are relevant and you can keep up your burst otherwise literally just use Festering Desire.  


Conclusion

Since all the new weapons have very specific situations for when they're actually meaningfully better than what already exists, they're a very easy skip.  This is compounded by the fact that the other weapons on the 1st rotation banner aren't particularly generally useful either.  Thus, unless you're an ultra whale who doesn't give a **** or you have a specific detailed goal in mind AND you're okay playing that big ass lottery, don't pull on it and wait for a weapon banner with 2 general good use 5*'s instead.  


For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.

Genshin Impact • Guides & Analyses
Guides & Walkthroughs
453
65
103
453
1
All comments 65

Loading...

All Tools

Recommended Users