Post Details Page

The One Trapped between Two Choices of Loyalty

Kaeya Alberich


Though it is said as "villains", most characters nowadays are more likely to fall in the "antagonists" category, as they oppose the protagonist or have a different approach method rather than being outright evil beings.


A man that is more on the brain side rather than the brawn, a strategic thinker and a charming gentleman who keeps his secrets tightly and makes the others spill theirs. The unique part is, as some people dislike him and consider him as a villain who will betray us someday, the other people think that he is loyal and a good person despite his cunning words. A man whose backstory is still mostly unknown and whose future is still ambiguous...


WARNING! A LOT OF SPOILERS AHEAD!


The World Is Not Black and White


Sometimes, a person's strength is more defined by their wits rather than pure physical (or magical) strength. Kaeya's strength, as said in-game Character Story 1, is his charming words in coaxing people into opening up their secrets. Some would say that it is dirty, but we have to do everything in order to protect our loved ones, don't we? This, if it is completely true, tells us that he is loyal to Mondstadt.


Hunters and bandits alike are often among Kaeya's drinking buddies. As wary of him as they may initially be, all are ultimately disarmed by his smooth talking, and end up telling him everything he wants to know.


In Character Story 2, we know that he is a person doing things in "the end justifies the means" manner. He would not hesitate to use any ways, no matter how they look to the outsiders and the dubious morality alignment with various risks of danger not only to himself, if it means getting what he wants.


"Justice is not an absolute principle, but is the result of striking that fine balance between strength and strategy. As for the details of how it's done... Don't worry yourself too much about that."

As longs as everything falls into place the way he expects in the end, Kaeya doesn't care all that much about the means.

Once, in order to force a bandit leader into facing him directly, Kaeya triggered the Ruin Guard at an ancient ruin to cut his opponent off, putting his own men at risk in the process.


Of course it could be just him being confident in his ability to keep them save or his judgement that the knights would definitely handle the situation well enough (they are alive, aren't they?). But there is an additional information in his "List" of criminals, implicitly tells us that he has the tendency of making things interesting, whatever that indicates.


"Otherwise, things would get too boring."


In stories, the main character often has the impossible ability to always stay on the positive and completely good side and always win, with those plot armors, the power of love and friendship, and whatnot. But the opposite party does not have the luxury of living like that, most likely than not from their own experience in life. In Character Story 4 and "Vision" part, we find out that he is abandoned with the specific purpose of being a spy but doesn't really want to do the obligation anymore; whether or not he is actually a sleeper rather than a simple spy... we may not know until the very (tragic?) end.


"One afternoon near the end of summer a decade ago, my father and I passed by the Dawn Winery."

"'I'll go get us some grape juice for the road,' he said, but he never came back."

"If Master Crepus hadn't taken me in, I doubt I'd have made it through the storm that night."

This matter-of-fact description hides a carefully constructed lie.

Kaeya has never once spoken the truth about what happened that afternoon:

"This is your chance. You are our last hope."

There was a side to Kaeya that he kept hidden from the world:

In truth, he was an agent of Khaenri'ah, placed in Mondstadt to serve their interests

If Khaenri'ah and Mondstadt went to war, which side should he support?

To whom should he offer his assistance: his birth father, who had ruthlessly abandoned him?

Or his adoptive father, who had loved him and raised him?.


Between duty to those in need and loyalty to those whom you owe, which one would you choose if you cannot do both? If one betrays what he is born to do, does that make that person a bad person? Or fulfilling it without consideration of which sides is wrong? What if both parties are wrong? Or neither are at fault?


In Character Story 5, his reaction to Master Crepus' passing could not be categorized as... well, normal perhaps not the exact word since humans often laugh after facing a traumatic event to reduce the trauma; but the fact we don't know what he was thinking about is already suspicious. It could be relief that he does not have to betray the man that had took him in, perhaps it is simply about the unexpected event itself... or something else actually sinister in nature.

Sinister thoughts flashed through Kaeya's mind, and he simply smirked:

"This world is truly... fascinating."


His backstory has not been revealed completely, but the bits of information we can gather has already told us his complicated and chained life. Born to shoulder the mistakes of his ancestors without having a say in it, but would people even understand his situation were he to explain it? In my opinion, his tendency of making things interesting could be because he thinks it is unfair that he should be the only one to suffer, he expects them to hate and hurt him, so he does the same. Not a good reason, but a reason nonetheless.


The Main Reason He Is Considered as a Villain by People


People often see him in unfavorable light, especially involving his method of handling things. In the Webtoon, there was a case when Kaeya drew out a possible enemy in a brash manner. Some people have the opinion that she is just a child, but so is he when he was sent to harm Mondstadt sooner or later. Some people disapprove of him handling Collei's case, but we can say that in his eyes, even children could be a serious threat. He is most likely saw himself in the same position as hers. One has said that we have to experienced the same thing to understand the same pain and let's be honest, would we just stand still as another child threatens to hurt our children? Kaeya most likely treats all Mondstadt's children as his to protect; like Klee for example (let's ignore his horrible influence for now).


Anyway, Collei's reaction to his attack is most likely resonates with his own thoughts of his situation. Some other people think that his reason to tell Diluc the truth was the same as Collei's; rather than having to choose between difficult choices, to shoulder the burdens that they have never asked for, they are better off dead before harming people without the meaning to.

Or in Kaeya's words:

Perhaps that makes him seeing the unfolded event in an... interesting way, I supposed. That there is the same situation as him with the same reaction, and makes the whole thing rather... bland, in a morbid way perhaps. That he had been hoping nobody has the similar case as him. Or perhaps, because this is the second time (of what we currently know) of his terrible wording... or the third if the way he explained to DIluc about his situation is as messed up, he is just terrible at expressing himself.


The Reason Why He is Memorable to Me


Jokes on you, it is not his "hot" entrance. When I first saw him in game, yes that first appearance of him clapping like a real villain, I actually disliked him; even more when I found out his flirty 'nature'[emoji]. I don't know if it's a good thing or not, but RNG did not side with me and the strange turn of fate (?) makes me a Kaeya main [emoji]. For reasons unknown even to myself, he has never left my party and strangely enough, despite disliking him, I use him the most and still do until now. Thus his background story gets revealed as his friendship level goes up. Well, they say that getting know someone often makes your perspective of them changes drastically; I went from disliking him to loving him more than any other characters. There are reasons how a person becomes as they are in the present. I... can understand why he lies and continue to lies; why he prefer sweet words and keeping people in safe distance rather than being open. Trusting and revealing the truth has done him no good, leaving him with more trauma and scars rather than warmth and acceptance, why would he? Yet despite having to go through all of that pain (with the additional of whatever horror stuff he has seen in Khaenri'ah), he remains strong enough to protect Mondstadt, to continue fighting in life even when emotional stability is far away from home. He is lonely and most likely drinks to pretend everything is fine (indicated by his denial in voice lines and Serenitea Pot's voice lines).


"Lonely? Me? Not with someone here nagging me all the time, that's for sure."

"Why do you like to drink so much, Kaeya?"

"Well... largely because I like the taste.

But I can't deny that I also like how it makes me feel."

 "So what you mean is, you drink to numb the pain?"

"Goodness, look at you, leaping to conclusions... Do I look like I've been through that much?"


Yes, you have. Stop doing that for one second-


I have grown a massive soft spot for him. He is my baby boy and I would destroy both Teyvat and Khaenri'ah for him. To abyss with the plot. I even pulled on weapon banner, as a pure F2P, for him. Forget meta, forget spiral abyss; Kaeya is my life. Everything must be sacrificed for him.


What I admire is, he can manage to rise and continue to fight despite being in one of his lowest state after the fight with Diluc and smile through it all. He shows that he still cares about his estrange brother (and probably the said man has the same feeling, with keeping the atrocious vase. As much as I love him, that thing is hideous). Most likely he has already forgiven him, or thinks there is nothing to be forgiven in the first place. Forgiveness is expensive and a difficult thing to give. Even being disliked and distrusted by many people he protects, he still protects them with his own way.


What I wish for his future is, whatever comes in the future, he is already happy enough in life without burning regrets in his final moments, or his loved ones... if it is possible...[emoji]


...


You know what? Forget it. Let me adopt him this instance right in front of his dear brother... and hope to be able to run fast enough not to suffer his mighty flaming bird. Completely worth it.


Simply to put, Kaeya can be both a Villain and a Hero, depending on the perspective, depending on how the story goes... Though, do someone can be classified as villain or hero based on how destiny decides when they are born? Or the sides they have taken? Or some of their doings?


Images Sources and References:

In game screenshots and character's profile

Kaeya Official Image

Kaeya Clapping gif

Genshin Impact Webtoon

HoYoLAB • Reality LAB
Villains
Kaeya
36
5
8
36
0
All comments 5

Loading...

All Tools

Recommended Users