Itsaroth, for people who don't know, is the God- not archon, of Time/Moments/Thousand winds. They're said to be of a higher status than the archons. (Or an elder god)
Here is what i propose: What is the unknown god at the start of the game is Istaroth? It makes sense since the unknown god was trying to prevent the travellers from being able to to freely move around Teyvat, and its as if she had been watching them for some time.
Also, this would explain her link to paimon, think about it.
Paimon knows a lot about the world around us as a guide, as if she had been watching for some *time*.
I'm not saying that paimon is the unknown god, but they could be linked in some way.
And Istaroth is an old God, which explains the unknown God's name 'Sustainer of Heavenly Principals,' its as if because she is like an 'elder god', she is the ultimate one who is watching over teyvat, with her many cubes representing her 'hundreds of eyes'.
But wait. what if because of khaenri'ah's advancement, so much so that they were 'ahead of time', istaroth is the reason why the cataclysm happened? because she wanted time in teyvat to be 'Sustained'. It would also explain the cubes in the story teaser abt when Lumine woke up first 500 years ago, coincidently the time when khaenri'ah fell.
So what's the final theory?
Istaroth is the unknown god. She stopped the travellers and took away their powers because she felt threatened by them, and had been watching them for a while. This happened around 500 years ago. When the first twin woke up, Istaroth was angered by khaenri'ah's advancement, as if they were ahead of time, so she called on the archons to destroy the place. but they couldn't say no to her, bc she's the elder god, and is way more powerful and has a higher status.
All because of her main worry: Time.
Perhaps she thinks that time is moving too fast for her liking, so she's doing everything she can to slow it down. Perhaps she is the one who instilled this idea of 'eternity' in the raiden twin's minds.
Anyway, this is my theory! what do you think? ^-^

