Evelyn Buff > Evelyn Set and it’s not close in my opinion (and since some people can’t be asked to read a single sentence, give other characters a buff first)
There are so many possibilities of what an Evelyn buff or an Evelyn Set could entail. She is doing perfectly fine in the current meta and the devs should definitely focus on other Agents, this is NOT A REAL THING! It’s just something I’ve been thinking about recently.
So many people for a long time have wanted an “Evelyn Disc Drive Set” and I think that’s quite a valid thing. But nowadays with Potential Unlocks and her options in set it’s much less needed. Also an ‘Evelyn Set’ could mean many things. Ideally it would be something like the Chain Attack version of Dawns Bloom. But who knows, the 2pc could be something completely useless like Electric DMG Bonus for a new Chain Attack based DPS, likely an Evelyn Replacement.
She already has multiple disc options as of current. Woodpecker can perform okay, but not reccomend if you don’t have her signature. Hormone Punk is very strong but hard to keep the uptime on.
Astral Voice and Puffer Electro are by far her best though, however they require specific teams. If you have Dialyn, put her on Puffer. If you have Astra (On Moonlight Lullaby) then use Astral Voice. Both their 2pc and 4pc effects are useful on Evelyn.
If instead that Extra Chain Attack damage was put into her P2 to P6, she could still reap the benefits of the 4pc set she’s using.
As for her Potential 1, I’m not too sure what to do with it. Something to give more chain attacks or more quick assists? Give her parts of her Hollow Zero Kit? Maybe an extension of her recourses / meter (think Burnice’s Buff). But it has a lot of… Potential(sorry) to be something much better than a new disc drive set.
[Edit]: There’s something else I just thought about. Many Limited S-Rank characters will get a buff at some point, not all and probably not even most will but Evelyn feels like one they would buff eventually. If they made a Chain Attack Set and made part of her buff Increase the Damage of Chain Attacks, wouldn’t it start to become oversaturated. I don’t know if it works the same as like too much Attack or Crit DMG can become oversaturated, I’m not that good at math. But like, at some point you’d get so much Chain Attack Damage and not just general damage on her Basic String, Ex Specials and the occasional Parry or Dodge Counter, which is a decent portion of her damage. It also may not be and I’m just dumb. But if feels like she gets so much there comes a point it starts to become redundant right? (I’M NOT SURE)