2 new 5*’s and 2 new free 4*’s. Let’s start with the gacha ones.
Engulfing Lightning

Increases to 56% conversion up to 120% and 50% ER after burst at R5
ER’s kind of a weird stat where you can substitute against offensive stats if you actually need your burst for comparative purposes, but if you don’t particularly need your burst then it’s not worth that much, and the fact that you need variable ER depending on what you’re fighting means you can have over indexing/waste. Anyways, just considering the ER focus, Engulfing Lightning’s comparison weapon would be Skyward Spine. If you don’t use normal attacks, then Lightning is always stronger since just from the weapon’s substat ER you’re getting ~15% atk%, which is equivalently worth ~10% crit, which is higher than Spine’s 8% crit. Not to mention with the 30% ER after burst that value goes up to ~24% atk%. If you do use normal attacks, then Spine will give you more offensive value but much less ER.
As for comparison with the 3 offensive weapons, if you want to assume that the ER from the weapon fully substitutes against offensive stats, then you’ll need to make up ~20% atk% give or take at R1, which you’ll clear when the 2nd part of the affix is active. If you need it to make up the whole offensive affix, you’re looking at ~40% atk% give or take which needs ~140% extra ER at R1 or an extra ~55% on top of the substat and affix active. If the full offensive sub-stat is included too, then you’ll need to cap out on the affix at over 300%. Unless you actually need the 185%+ ER the weapon gives you, it’s almost certainly going to be weaker than any offensive weapon, though you can get further offsets if you have additional scaling on ER such as with Emblem or Raiden passive.
For character specific users:
Hu Tao: Isn’t burst reliant, doesn’t need that much ER, Homa is a weapon, moving on.
Raiden Shogun: You all really think Raiden’s signature weapon wouldn’t be good on her? Just between the ~85% ER from this weapon converted to offensive stats from her A2 and Emblem and the atk% from the affix from that ER + her ascension stats, she pretty much already outscales the substat + affix for any offensive weapon, not even taking into account the increased support ability for her burst. When miHoYo goes out of their way to make a signature weapon for a character, use that weapon on said character.
Rosaria: She is burst dependent regardless of what she’s being used as, but she’s on the lower end of ER requirements with her particle generation and C4 and she’s also crit dependent for her support ability. If you’re not running a crit substat weapon on her, then frankly she’d probably still prefer Spine over Lightning since its substat is more in her required range for ER and it gives crit (albeit a relatively minimal amount) for her A2.
Xiangling: Needs a relatively large amount of ER (moreso if sitting in reserve all the time), especially since Guoba has brain damage from all the chili peppers she force fed him. Pretty much any composition where Bennett isn’t also included she needs more than 200% ER and even when Bennett is in the party she needs a decent amount. Not to mention she runs Emblem since her burst is the only relevant damage portion of her kit so the ER has more offensive offset. You’ll do more damage with an offensive weapon, but that’s predicated on being able to maintain her burst which this weapon will let you do comfortably and Xiangling is almost entirely dependent on her burst so if you want more consistency, Lightning is the way to go.
Xiao: If there’s any case where you need this much ER, you are probably doomed for damage on Xiao anyways. Not to mention the period after he casts burst is exactly the period he can’t get energy because he’s in his burst and can’t swap off or use elemental skill himself because they don’t generate energy so that’s wasted outside of enemy drops and if he uses E right before burst.
Zhongli: Doesn’t really need burst outside of control situations and if you want to use burst for damage then you actually want offensive stats for damage and not this much ER. Homa also still exists as a weapon for more damage and support on him so.
Verdict: Good for characters that need burst for their core operation and are high ER requirement (~180%+); otherwise it’s just better to use one of the offensive 5* with either a few ER substats or an ER sands if you still need your burst.
Everlasting Moonglow

Increases to 20% Healing Bonus and 3% on Normal Attack
Well, it’s not comparable to the other 3 5* offensive catalysts because Moonglow literally gives HP% scaling and healing bonus with some energy recovery, none of which sounds like pure offensive focus at all. If anything, it’s better to compare it to Prototype Amber and Dragon Slayer. Amber actually regenerates more energy than Moonglow in most situations and definitely at higher refinements. You expect the Healing Bonus on Moonglow to outgain the team HP recovery effect on Amber, but really outside of the higher base stats and offensive effect it doesn’t add much. Dragon Slayer is weaker on everything compared to those two, but can buff another member of the team with 48% atk% with 50% uptime. Pretty much Moonglow is good only if you scale off HP and you heal and you attack, which isn’t exactly the biggest universe of characters.
For character specific users:
Everyone not named Kokomi or Barbara: I don’t see any healing here, do you?
Barbara herself anyways: If you’re using Barbara as a healer, you really don’t want to attack anyways, you definitely don’t want to attack after you use burst, and if you need the healing bonus and slightly higher HP% substat on this weapon to keep your team alive then you have bigger problems to worry about.
Kokomi: The only character who scales offensively off all of these stats and also wants to attack. Well, that isn’t even necessarily true depending on your composition but she’s the only character who will ever have that situation. It’s the highest damage weapon for her but Amber is almost certainly going to be sufficient for keeping the team alive so the added offensive is pretty much the only relevant concern for the weapon.
Verdict: Yeah it’s the best weapon for Kokomi. You better really like Kokomi if you’re going to sink up to 240 pulls for a modest offense increase compared to a free craftable 4* catalyst.
The Catch

Scales up to 32% dmg% and 12% crit rate.
Since The Catch is a free 4* weapon, then the comparison is with other free/craftable 4*’s. The two physical ones have a completely different focus, so no substitution there. Kitain is kind of weird to compare against. 110 EM is about a ~20% true damage increase on vaporize and melt assuming you have no EM and around a ~83% damage increase to flat reactions. If you have no EM and a lot of dmg%/crit that applies to your burst, it can possibly be more damage depending on reactions but unlikely. It also in all likelihood will generate less energy than the ER from catch since it’s at most 12 energy every 10s, which most compositions generate more than ~26 energy needed for the ER to win out (not to mention enemy drops). As for between Catch and Starglitter, they’re completely different focuses. Both have the same stats, but Catch is focused on enhancing your burst while Starglitter is focused on characters who need burst but nevertheless focus on normal attacks.
For character specific users:
Hu Tao: Not burst dependent, burst isn’t a super large portion of her damage profile, and honestly you might not want to use your burst that often because it makes it difficult to keep your HP below 50% with the healing possibly. Since you can’t maintain 2 stacks of Starglitter and Hu Tao vaporizes a very large portion of her damage, you’re honestly best off using Kitain out of all the free options, especially since you don’t particularly need the refinements for energy either.
Raiden Shogun: Scales offensively off of ER and since all her damage is elemental burst dmg%, can’t use Starglitter so the obvious and only choice is Catch. Note that with all her dmg% dilution from A2 and Emblem, Catch isn’t as good as it seems like it would be on her but it’s still very solid.
Rosaria: If you’re running her as a physical DPS, then you use one of the physical weapons. If you’re running her as a cryo DPS, then it’s debatable since while normal/charged attacks would make up a slightly larger portion of her damage profile compared to her burst, the enhancement to her burst from Catch is larger than Starglitter and in practice you probably end up attacking less than expected. If you’re just using her for her burst, then you would use Catch… unless you happen to be able to reverse melt all her ticks in which case Kitain would have competitive damage and she can use the affix well. In practical terms, the difference isn’t huge in the latter two cases and frankly you can just save the 5 prototypes you’d sink in otherwise.
Xiangling: If you’re not vaporizing her burst, then Catch is the way to go. If you are vaporizing her burst then it’s the same situation with Rosaria burst and Kitain’s EM. Xiangling does go Emblem so the ER gives some offensive value but as such the dmg% is more diluted, though if you have EM elsewhere Kitain also falls off. You’ll probably still do more damage with Catch in most cases and also it lets you save prototypes like above.
Xiao: Repeat after me: miHoYo hates Xiao.
Zhongli: Well, Zhongli doesn’t auto and also he doesn’t use EM, so this makes Catch the only weapon that isn’t just missing a third of its value. Zhongli isn't super burst dependent but hey it actually has a good ratio and the affix could actually help push it to relevant enough damage that you want to use it in your rotation solely for that reason.
Verdict: It’s super solid on any burst focused damage character and is very cohesive thematically, since ER is literally so you can charge your burst and a lot of the time the reason you want to charge your burst is because said burst does damage, as compared to something like Festering Desire which is more constrained. And it’s not tied to an event so it won’t disappear like other free weapons, banzai.
Luxurious Sea-Lord

Whoops wrong tuna

Scales up to 24% dmg% and 200% atk
I still can’t get over the fact that this is a fish.
Anyways, looks aside, Sea-Lord seems to be a weird hybrid between The Catch and Prototype Archaic. And it’s not automatically better than Archaic despite having a dmg% increase as opposed to just a damage dealing affix; there are characters who don’t get much damage from their burst and the base attack getting outscaled is even more prominent due to the atk% substat. That being said, Archaic is a generally solid weapon, so any weapon that’s similar and relatively general is also going to be solid.
Using Archaic as the baseline general weapon, Sea-Lord is the more burst focused variant and Starsilver is the physical damage variant. Naturally, there’s going to be more overlap between Archaic and Sea-Lord since most people use burst compared to being physical focused. Whiteblind doesn’t have direct competition with Sea-Lord since it’s a stat (def) focused weapon rather than any specific part of the kit. Nagamasa is focused on burst but strictly for charging it and cannot compete offensively, though if you can’t use your burst in the first place it defeats the purpose of having it.
For character specific users:
Beidou: Is incredibly burst focused and can proc the fish portion with good uptime and is not so energy starved to need Nagamasa. Also she’s a pirate who lives on the sea that killed a giant sea monster so what fits better than wielding a giant fish.
Chongyun: Well, his burst is the part of his kit that does the most damage, but since it’s a 12s cd he actually has worse uptime on the fish since he can’t proc it every burst and if he waits until the cd is ready well then he’s delaying his burst and decreasing his damage that way. This is as opposed to Archaic’s cd being the same as his e cd. He’s not so energy starved to need Nagamasa though. Isn’t too big of a difference between Sea-Lord and Archaic, so you can just use whichever one you have.
Diluc: Same issue with the 12s cd, not to mention his burst against most enemies is just a way to get his pyro enchantment and not a large portion of his damage profile. Still isn’t really that big of a difference between Sea-Lord and Archaic though, so no big reason to get one if you have the other.
Eula: Eula actually gets good mileage out of Starsilver’s affix since she’s cryo, for 720% every 20s as opposed to only 200% every 20s from Sea-Lord and since she’s also physical focused that damage difference is actually somewhat relevant. That being said, Eula has a lot of sources of physical dmg% so the substat from Starsilver might actually be more diluted than Sea-Lord’s, though Sea-Lord’s affix has the same issue. Though, you literally have copies of both of these weapons for free so you don’t actually have to choose between them.
Noelle: Only the initial hit of the burst gets amplified by Sea-Lord’s affix, so it gets very poor mileage. No reason to use it over Whiteblind.
Razor: Same issue as Noelle on the burst damage increase, though Razor is also super diluted on physical dmg% since his ascension stat is it as well, and again you don’t have to choose between Sea-Lord and Starsilver since you get both for free.
Sayu: Sayu’s burst is a non-trivial portion of her damage, so that part of the affix will get decent mileage on top of it being generally useful for her otherwise. Maybe if you really need energy you can use Nagamasa instead but otherwise Sea-Lord is fine.
Xinyan: If you’re just using her as a skill/burst swap, well her burst does do the largest portion of her damage and isn’t entirely physical either. If you actually plan on using her as main DPS though, both her shield value and C6 scale off of def so you’d use Whiteblind, though you actually need refinements on it since otherwise you’ll be losing out too much atk% as opposed to having comparable atk% to other weapons but with extra def%.
Verdict: If you’ve been playing since launch, then you’ll have an Archaic, Starsilver, and Sea-Lord all for free, and Sea-Lord’s the one that will be R5 from the event, which is great since it’s the one that scales most with them. Even if it might be worse than Archaic in some situations, I don’t know a single person who would complain about getting a free comparable to R5 Archaic weapon and it’s still a generally solid weapon even when you can’t really use the affix.
Am I the only one who likes the 4*’s better than the 5*’s this patch? Both from an aesthetic perspective and a general usability perspective.
Oh yeah I forgot about Predator but I don't own a Playstation console so.
For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.


