Post Details Page

[Version 2.2] 2.2 Character Rundown Thoma Part 1

So I hadn’t done the new hangouts yet, but then someone told me that Thoma was playable in his hangout, so then I did his hangout and now here we are.  

Table of Contents

Introduction

Talents

Constellations

Role

Investment

Conclusion

Introduction

Thoma’s a pyro polearm user who generates shields.  He’s pretty much the result of people wanting a pyro Xingqiu but miHoYo not wanting to give us a pyro Xingqiu so here we are.  

Talents

Normal Attack: Thoma’s normal attack is a 4-hit sequence where he does some cool acrobatics that you will never use because miHoYo loves giving the characters that you never use normals on the super cool looking ones.  His charged attack is the forward spiraling type.  

Elemental Skill: Thoma does a frontal kick flip, dealing pyro damage and applying pyro to himself.  Simultaneously, he’ll shield himself (scaling with HP) with a shield that lasts 8s which is 250% effective against pyro.  Gaining new shields from his burst or skill will refresh this duration and stack with existing shields up to a certain amount scaling with Thoma’s elemental skill level.  Has a 15s cd and generates 3-4 particles.  

Elemental Burst: Thoma deals AoE pyro damage around himself.  Afterwards, he creates a ward that follows the active character and shoots out a frontal wave of flame (that has an angle of ~45-60 degrees give or take) whenever they normal attack, up to once per second.  With each flame wave, he will gain additional shielding stacking with his existing shielding with the same upper limit depending on his elemental skill.  Is an 80/20 burst.  

A1: When the active character gains or refreshes the shield from Thoma, that specific active character gains 5% shield strength for 6s.  Maximum of 5 stacks with 0.3s cd on stack gain.

A2: Flame waves from Thoma’s burst deal an additional 2.2% of Thoma’s max HP as damage.  

Passive:  When fishing in Inazuma, 20% chance of double catch where was this last patch oi.  

Constellations

C1: When any character but Thoma gets hit while Thoma’s shield is active on them, Thoma’s skill and burst cd are both reduced by 3s.  Can only occur once every 20s.  

C2: Thoma’s burst duration is extended by 3s 

C4: Thoma’s burst refunds 15 energy.

C6: When the shield from Thoma is gained or refreshed, all party members gain 15% normal/charged/plunge dmg% for 6s.  

Role Breakdown

Pyro Shielder (C0; C4+ preferred) 

Alright, so this is what I imagine happened.  People wanted a Xingqiu for another element (understable because he’s a good enabler for many comps).  miHoYo thinks that Xingqiu is too strong of a character (understandable as he offers a lot and offers them well).  They think something like ~70% of Xingqiu’s current power might be a good spot.  So do you A) pick the ~70% of the parts of Xingqiu’s kit you want Thoma to do well, focus on that and then cut out the other ~30%, B) nerf Xingqiu (which is and always has been legal despite what you guys keep wanting to believe) so he doesn’t crowd out the field, or C) do neither and do something weird instead?


miHoYo: “Let’s just take all of Xingqiu’s areas, focus on exactly one to amplify, then cut the rest of them by some seemingly arbitrary amount as long as in total they average out to ~70% total power give or take and then give that to Thoma.”


No, but seriously Xingqiu and Thoma are pretty much the same character by design outside of their element.  Both of them are characters who have a fancy looking normal attack you never use, a long cd skill with mechanics tied to their burst, ward type bursts that require you to normal attack every second for maximum effectiveness that hit in a cone shaped frontal area which you want to maintain with 100% uptime, have a defensive A1 and offensive A2, all rounded out with defensive support ability.  The difference in their efficacy is simply due to the degree in which these different parts of their kits are fleshed out, and Thoma did not get a very good fleshing out.


Let’s start with their defensive focus, just because that seems to be Thoma’s core identity while only a supplemental part of Xingqiu’s kit.  Xingqiu’s defensive support is his ability to regenerate 18% (24% at C1) of his HP to another character every ~20s, while providing dmg% reduction almost all the time as well.  Assuming you only have a hydro dmg% cup and his A2 (since most people run Emblem and not Depth 2-set anymore), that’s up to ~42% dmg reduction depending on skill level.  In other words, if you would’ve taken 10,000 damage, Xingqiu would mitigate 4,200 of it.  This is more valuable the more damage you would’ve taken, but let’s just consider the amount he could refund with his healing.  At lvl 90 just considering a +20 flower, Xingqiu has ~15,000 HP, which means he’ll restore ~3600 HP.  Taking the mitigation into account, you can take ~6,200 damage pre-mitigation and be fully restored by that.


Now let’s consider Thoma.  Don’t let the hangout value of 22,667 HP fool you; if you check his stats, his base HP is only 10,187 at lvl 88, which means at lvl 90 it’s ~10,300.  That’s almost the lowest among melee characters in this game and only higher than… Xingqiu, and Thoma will also have ~15,000 HP just with a +20 flower.  If we assume his E follows standard talent scaling, then at lvl 13 it would be ~15% and ~1900, which would be ~4,200 shield against non-pyro damage.  Again using normal talent scaling, his burst would give him ~2.4% and ~300 HP per stack, which is ~660.  So, after E + 3 flame waves Thoma can provide as much damage mitigation through shielding as Xingqiu and every 20s Thoma can provide about ~20,000 shielding, which would require ~50,000 damage taken while under Xingqiu burst to even out.  Not to mention shields provide absolute resistance to interruption, whereas Xingqiu provides resistance but not absolute immunity to interruption.


There are other nuances (Xingqiu dmg reduction boosts shields effectiveness, can only heal one target, needs to be on said target during expiration; Thoma has A1 for increased effectiveness, needs time to stack his shield, must actually take damage since the total amount would be capped at ~11,500 with 15,000 base hp at lvl 13 etc.).  However, in a general sense, Thoma is indeed better at defensive utility than Xingqiu.  Let’s not be biased here and say Xingqiu is better than Thoma in every single way, because that’s not true.  That being said, that’s pretty much the only area Thoma exceeds Xingqiu in combat.


Because outside of that, Thoma doesn’t really have anything going for him.  To start off, Thoma’s rotational set-up is worse.  Xingqiu and Thoma both have long cd skills.  The difference is, sacrificial sword actually exists in the game while sacrificial spear does not, so while Xingqiu can use that weapon to burst and get energy, Thoma can’t.  But even putting that aside, Thoma’s way more clunky.  Because Xingqiu’s E is pretty much the same cd as his Q, you can fit his entire rotation into one short period and you only have a short downtime (~3s) where his Q isn’t active.  Thoma’s E cd is shorter than his Q cd by 5s, so you either have to awkwardly swap him in during the middle of his burst for his skill then swap to him again later to refresh the burst, or you just wait the extra 5s and drop an extreme amount of energy efficiency on a skill that’s already not high energy in the first place.  Not to mention Thoma’s pretty energy hungry and if you have his C1 his E+Q skill cds will be shorter but only some of the time to add another layer of hassle to use.  


Then we have the damage.  Assuming standard scaling, Thoma’s E will end up ~300% while his Q will end up ~190% and ~125% at lvl 13.  Those are both way weaker than Xingqiu, his Q significantly so.  A C6 Xingqiu can theoretically get ~6900% skill scaling every 20s from his burst.  In the same time period Thoma’s burst can’t even reach 2700% or barely higher than a third of Xingqiu burst.  Not to mention, because the flame waves share ICD, his pyro application is only about a third of Xingqiu’s hydro application (technically less because with C6 Xingqiu applies hydro twice every 3rd wave).  This inhibits both his utility and damage as a result.  


If we’re being entirely technical, Xingqiu’s non-direct combat abilities are pretty much just straight better than Thoma’s.  Xingqiu’s A1+A2 are more generally useful than Thoma’s as far as offensive/defensive skills go.  As for constellations, Thoma might as well just be missing a constellation.  C’mon, Xingqiu’s C2 is literally just Thoma’s C2 except it has an extra effect.  Xingqiu’s C1+C2+C6 are just as good as if not better as a group than Thoma’s C1+C2+C4+C6, seeing as you know Xingqiu’s C2 is literally Thoma’s but better and his C6 can technically be superior to Thoma’s C4 + it increases his burst damage by a third.  


Okay okay fine, comparing Thoma to Xingqiu might be considered bullying since they neither share the same element nor the same core focus, since Thoma is on defense while Xingqiu is on offense.  Let’s compare to a character with the same core focus then: C0 Zhongli vs. C6 Thoma.  Zhongli is the quintessential character with defensive focus.  Not to mention, they literally have almost identical distributed A1+A2, have an offensive portion tied to their shields (res down vs. dmg% up), and poor/somewhat irrelevant elemental application.


Because Zhongli has ~40% more base HP than Thoma, the most favorable comparison for Thoma is when neither of them have any HP% sources and only the +20 flower, since that value is flat regardless.  With just a +20 flower at lvl 10, Zhongli’s shield is ~7200.  However, due to being geo it has a 1.5 multiplier at all times, as opposed to Thoma’s which has a 2.5 multiplier but only against pyro.  Thus, Zhongli’s shield is effectively ~10,800.  Thus, in order for Thoma to match Zhongli’s shield outside of pyro, he needs to both use his E and then proc his Q 10 times, which will take 10s at the very least, compared to Zhongli’s shield with a 12s cd.  Not to mention Thoma’s shield is capped and without his E it is slow to build back up, while Zhongli refreshes it entirely with cast.


Outside of shielding, Zhongli is better at support while Thoma’s better at damage (well I say that under the assumption you don’t actually try to hit Zhongli pillar pulses but if you do their damage difference is pretty much negligible).  Their A1+A2 is pretty much a wash (Thoma’s A1 is generally better while Zhongli’s A2 numerically is).  Zhongli’s support outside of his shield is in his 20% res down + control.  Not to mention he can use Noble, Petra, and Millelith as support sets depending on how much you want to turn off your brain.  Thoma’s only support outside of his shield is on his C6 for normal/charged/plunging dmg%, which is much more restricted than 20% res down.  Not to mention he can’t use Petra or Milelith (which given Thoma is literally a shielder who scales off HP% really doesn’t make sense) and is a worse user of Noble.


Putting the control and set usage aside, just comparing the 20% res down to the dmg%, Zhongli is way more generally useful there.  The first 10% res down is typically the most important (since most enemies have 10% res and everything past 0 is halved), and unlike Viridescent’s res down, it works even when enemies have innate elements and it works on all of a character’s damage.  Normal/charged/plunge dmg% is a more restricted portion of your damage and has more dilution with other dmg%.  If you’re taking Thoma against pyro enemies for more shield effectiveness, that’s all you're getting outside of his shield.  And technically speaking, getting a C0 Zhongli is cheaper on average than a C6 Thoma though you can get the C6 Thoma while pulling for something else. 


Okay, Thoma’s not completely outclassed there but in most situations you’d prefer the Zhongli and not the Thoma.  How about we compare him with another high burst cost pyro character with area coverage, Xiangling?  After all, you get a copy of her for free and probably have a few constellations at the very least for her.  Xiangling’s pretty much entirely offensive focused.  She generates no shield compared to Thoma ofc.  However, she has an atk% buff, a pyro dmg% buff, and a pyro res shred compared to just Thoma’s normal/charged/plunged dmg% buff.  Her E (albeit derpy targeting) does ~3x the damage and technically generates more particles too.  Not to mention her burst practically has the same frontal coverage as his (I swear Guoba’s flames have better coverage than Thoma’s burst) with better circular coverage.  And it doesn’t require you to basic attack every second to trigger it since it’s autonomous.  And it applies pyro about 3x as often.  And it snapshots.


Given all that, you’d at least expect Thoma’s burst to have the same ratio right?  Nah, it’s like a third weaker give or take.  In other words, you can take the above as the tradeoff between the two.  Let’s be generous and say their support ability and energy generation are a wash.  Then, you’re giving up at least a third of your damage, around two-thirds of your elemental application, and a fair bit of AoE for a shield.  As such, despite some similarities the two share, they really can’t substitute between each other.  However, it does pretty much let you know that outside of situations that require high defense, there isn’t really a reason to run Thoma over Xiangling.


Alright, we’re really scraping the barrel here, but maybe we ought to do a final comparison between Thoma and Xinyan because they’re literally both pyro units with a shield.  Assuming Xinyan has no sources of DEF%, she’ll generate a ~4300 shield with max stacks on her E, which is only slightly stronger than Thoma’s E and weaker if it’s one of the weaker ones (though she can guarantee max stacks with her C2 with high uptime).  Assuming she maintains her E pyro ticks and casts her burst with 100% uptime, she’ll still actually be slightly lower than Thoma on damage.  Not to mention, outside of 2 characters' bursts and some weapon effects, the only things that deal physical damage are normal/charged/plunging attacks, except those can also be elemental.


That being said, Xinyan has advantages over Thoma too.  For one, she can also reduce phys res for additional support.  She can use sacrificial claymore b/c of her E cd and the fact that sacrificial claymore exists unlike sacrificial spear.  Not to mention her pyro application is technically better than his (every 2s compared to every 3s) if her max stage shield is active.  And she’s autonomous and easy to use compared to his burst requiring you to normal attack.  She also can be run as a main DPS focused on charged attacks, whereas Thoma is stuck in support.  Not that I would use Xinyan over Thoma in most situations, because the higher shield value from Thoma in almost every scenario is going to be more useful than the auxiliary benefits listed above.  That being said, I really can’t consider it a W that Thoma’s only marginally better than a character that has identity issues, mostly due to the fact that he has an identity (pure shielding).


Because seriously, outside of the fact that Thoma’s the only other character aside from Zhongli who can easily maintain a 100% uptime shield (since other shields have shorter duration than their cd or are super paper like crystallize), I can’t really see any particular synergies or uses for him.  Putting aside the fact that his burst isn’t particularly high damage in the first place, only one third of it can react and only applies pyro once every 3s.  You get incredibly poor mileage out of vaporize (one-sixth damage increase) and frankly the frequency is low enough that cryo units trying to melt off of him might have issues.  Not to mention, if you try to tag him with another pyro for resonance and the shield, it’s sporadic enough that it can mess up the application for vaporize, particularly if you don’t have a C6 Xingqiu to guarantee reapplication of hydro every 3rd wave.  


Which gives us two more options: since the application is super slow, then you could melt each one of them or you could use it with swirl who doesn’t really care about application speed when fighting multiple enemies.  If you do melt them, then you’re getting about a third increase to your damage (so around Diluc on a bad day and higher than Yoimiya at least).  I’m not sure if it’s worth it to have Thoma be the one amplified with his low damage as opposed to the reverse, and more importantly you can’t use it with freeze.  Not a particularly ideal situation regardless and not one I can see happening much.  As for anemo, most anemo characters are not dependent on their normal/charged/plunged for damage.  The ones that are would be Xiao (dmg% diluted to the moon) and C6 Kazuha (also dmg% diluted to the moon).  So if anything, Thoma would be something that works, but not something that works particularly well.


Frankly, I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s probably best to just treat him as a more difficult to use Zhongli without nearly as much support ability with the mechanical execution requirement of Xingqiu.  His elemental application is infrequent to the extent that it’s typically too unreliable to count on and in some situations it can be detrimental to you( just like Zhongli’s pillar resonance).  However, he still can maintain his shield with 100% coverage and the amount is relatively high.  I’m sure we’d all like a pyro Xingqiu, but Thoma isn’t that so we have to take him as is and use him around that.  


Continue to Part 2



For other character spot analysis, go to Sumeru Studies™.



Genshin Impact • Guides & Analyses
Guides & Walkthroughs
Character Review
Instructions for Newcomers
914
52
74
914
0
All comments 52

Loading...

All Tools

Recommended Users