HERRSCHER OF HUMAN: EGO

SILVERWING: NEX

Silverwing doesn’t have Charged ATK. From Willows-B, She can only enjoy 10% from max 25%.

Silverwing’s Ultimate only costs 75 SP. From Willows-3pc, She can only enjoy 5% from max 15%.

Nevertheless, Willows set is her best alternative if you don’t have any piece of Nex stigma.

Addition, Silverwing has high hit rate, Welt-M is good alternative. I forgot to test NexTB WeltM. It should be slightly better than NexTB WillowsM.

STARCHASM NYX

I’m not good at using Nyx. The result I got is kinda unstable. Unsure about the gap between Willows-TMB and Ana-TMB.

At least we know that Verne set is still her best stigma. Higher DMG, higher SP regen. And the gap with alternative is noticeable.

ARGENT KNIGHT: ARTEMIS

Argent Knight’s Ultimate consumes little SP at activation. From Willows-3pc, she can only enjoy 5% from max 15%.

Nevertheless, Willows set is her best stigma. Beside higher DMG, Willows-2pc also has extra SP regen which Ana set doesn’t have.

GOUSHINNSO MEMENTO

Memento doesn’t have Charged ATK. From Willows-B, She can only enjoy 10% from max 25%.

In this test, DMG from Ana-TMB and Willows-TMB are similar.

In real battle, Willows-TMB will drop when Memento doesn’t use Ultimate.

Her main DMG is from Combo ATKs, Ana-3pc is good for that. With or without Ultimate, Ana-TMB will be more consistent (not sure about Elysian Realm, not tested yet).

SUMMARY

For HoR and Argent Knight, Willows set is their best stigmata.

For other Ice DMG dealers, Willows set is an additional option as alternative stigmata.