Since I had some free time (and probably won’t have much for a while after this) and since this patch is relatively empty on things to write about, I figured this would be a good time to write this article.
Anyways, I see a lot of people who play one miHoYo game curious about other miHoYo games (since I do write both Tears of Themis (ToT) and Genshin (GI) articles after all). Getting a cross comparison of different games from the same company has two primary benefits. One, it helps inform you if you are considering taking up another game since you have something familiar to base it on. Two, companies often (though not necessarily) employ similar mechanisms between their games. If you’ve played Honaki (HK3) or ToT, you wouldn’t be surprised at the upcoming GI character banner structure at all, since both of those games have employed similar functional forms before to deal with having to rerun characters without having the space.
That being said, there seems to be a lot of incorrect information floating around on the topic. And don’t get me started on the incompetence of some CC’s (aka con-artist clickbaiters) who either are intentionally misinforming or plain dumb. Granted, I don’t have the numbers down pat to the 10th sig fig either, but I’ll at least tell you that. I did have the best beta stats by far in both GI and ToT after all, and I haven’t fallen off to the extent that I can’t give you accurate general values. As for HK3, I’m more out of sync since I no longer actively play it and there has been at least two major overhauls (Abyss and Elysian Realm) since I ceased activity. Not to mention I was only half decent at best when I did play it; I peaked out at slightly under 10% in Memorial Arena (I think I was like ~9.5%ish give or take) and was consistently retaining Red Lotus (though I might have had to bomb people in Dirac Sea occasionally LOL). (For what it’s worth I did peak out in top 20 APHO and #7 on the sensei ranking kek). (Granted I did spend more crystals on costumes for valks I never owned than on valks for combat so I might’ve been trolling). So treat Honkai’s section with the biggest grain of salt, got it? Also I unfortunately never played Honkai Gakuen or anything before that so I can’t draw comparisons there, nor did miHoYo bother to invite the person who’s given them the most substantive feedback in totality to Star Rail so I can’t speak on them either sorry.
Now then, for each of the games I’ll cover premium currency, other resource acquisition, alternative acquisition, gacha functionality, and gacha dependency. There’s probably more things I can cover but those seem to be the important things and easiest to compare as opposed to more gameplay specific things.
Premium Currency Acquisition

GI: Typical primogem equivalents comes out to about 10,000 per 1.5 months or slightly longer than a patch (which is also the expected value for a 5* funny how that works huh). In that amount, you get slightly more than half (5700) from the fixed sources of commissions (2700), spiral abyss (1800), and the stardust shop intertwined fates (1200). The rest comes from things such as events, maintenance compensation, codes, achievements etc. That comes out to 80,000 a year, on top of which you need to add another ~20,000 from extraneous large things such as new areas, celebration events etc. This gives you about 100,000 per year, which is approximately accurate if you look at Keebster’s 1-year tracking amount video.
In fact, it slightly undershoots the true value since Keebster hasn’t pulled enough to buy all the intertwined fate every month, so between the intertwined fate he should have and the primogems he possibly could have, that’s somewhere between the 100,000 and 110,000 mark. Not to mention the acquaint fates, which aside from not being able to give up-rate 5* characters and weapons, pretty much operate exactly the same as intertwined fates. I’ve spent more than 60 in standard banner and saved the rest, adding up to over 300 even if you subtract the 5 from free BP this patch. If you’ve actually pulled everything too, assuming you have standard rarity distribution you’ll have had enough stardust to buy all the intertwined and acquaint fate every month if that’s all you spent it on.
HK3: From Elspectra’s tracking back in the day, you ended up getting 10,000 or so gems every month as a low estimate assuming you were able to clear 2% in memorial and retain red lotus in Abyss. That was a while ago and gem amounts have only increased. Since then, Abyss has been overhauled to give more gems, and Elysian Realm was also added that I’m pretty sure also gives you more gems. You used to get around 60 pulls per 1.5 months, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that value was closer to 70 now.
ToT: ToT’s premium currency is actually a pain in the ass to track, not only because the frequency of events is pretty random because there isn’t a consistent patch schedule (I don’t think CN has one either really), but the total number of events every month varies anyways. Not to mention, while ToT has “big” events and “small” events, the amount of s-chips you get differs extremely wildly. The “big” events are all directly associated with new SSR cards. However, in the best case you have things such as Lost Gold where you could get almost 50 pulls equivalent worth of premium currency. Compare that to Symphony of the Night where we got 800 s-chips, which isn’t even 5 pulls. The guaranteed s-chips per month also only comes out to around ~3200 a month, which is almost 20% less than in GI. That being said, ToT gives out a lot of premium currency equivalent during celebrations and also during big patches such as story, so all-in-all you can expect close to 30-40 pulls a month on average, though it’ll fluctuate extensively.
Other Resource Acquisition

GI: Despite what people want to believe, there is no guaranteed resource deficiency in Genshin. After a year of gameplay, all my characters are at the very least lvl 70 2/6/6 in talents (6/6/6 if they use normal attacks). More than half of them are level 80, with some of them lvl 90 and up to 9/9/9 talents instead. Not to mention, I have the spare exp materials to get all my characters to 80 with extra to get some to 90 and over 30 million excess mora and I still haven’t done the 800 leyline achievement. I have all the boss mats necessary to fully ascend all my characters and at the latest I’ll have all the ascension gems I need in 2-3 months. If I had average luck on the ascension gem drops as well I’d already have cleared that threshold too (2.5 greens per boss mat and 10 greens per weekly boss as a high estimate; my actual numbers are lower). I’ve never used primogems to refresh resin and I’ve stopped doing artifact investigation runs and random events for over half a year, which is over a 50k loss of mora every day or over 7.5million mora I’m out of possibly.
I did buy several BPs which I’ve since stopped buying, but keep in mind I also have every character but Mona so I’m actually lower on other resources than I should be otherwise. Since BP is the 2nd cheapest source of primogem equivalents after the monthly card, anyone with my character distribution would’ve bought more BPs than I did, so they’d have more resources than I do assuming they’re a normal person and not slave labored by miHoYo. As for artifacts, I’ve spent approximately one fifth of my available resin in the past year in artifact domains. I’ve got passable artifacts for characters I use (~10 total rolls into 2 stats of my choice and ~5 rolls into other useful stats) with the correct 4-set or otherwise if I’m using a 2/2 set-up I’ll have more rolls of my choice because I’ll have a wider pool to choose from as a tradeoff. Which is why people actually complain about not having enough resources, because they’re chasing artifacts with twice those numbers of rolls. Getting additional offensive rolls gets exponentially harder, but if you accept a lower threshold with them you’ll have enough for even the characters you don’t use.
HK3: The notion that you’ll never be tight on resources is complete bs, and this sentiment is spread by boomers who’ve been at cap forever. You’ll pretty much never be tight on resources in two phases of the game: starting out and after you’ve been at cap for a while in a good armada. HK3 has a lot of beginner support, so you’ll never feel like you’re running into any issues while leveling up. Once you get to the 70-80 range, then you’ll feel the hell squeeze when you need multiple teams of invested valkyries depending on which bs MA bosses/Abyss weather miHoYo decides to throw out for that cycle. Don’t get me started on how much ELFs gobble up too; I swear those little ****s are even more expensive than valkyries. Once you get to cap, then you’ll drown in gold and gold in HK3 can be used to buy a lot of things including character and weapon exp. Not to mention you can scrap a bunch of different items into resources too. If you’re in a good armada you’ll also get more stuff and you can request the things you’re low on.
ToT: Don’t let this game trick you into thinking things are cheap. The thing about ToT is that things are super cheap early on and you’ll feel like you have everything you need for the first like 30 levels. Then you will go into resource hell and even worse resource hell when you need to get cards to 100 and skills to 10. For a comparative perspective, consider how many resources you need to get a character to lvl 90 in GI. That might get you a card to 100 in ToT, and in ToT you have 40 of those per deck. Now imagine how many resources you need to get all of a character’s talents to lvl 10. That won’t even get all three of a card’s skills to level 10 in ToT and again you have 40 of those. Good luck even getting your 15 card main deck all to lvl 100 with 10/10/10 talents in a year, even more so if those cards are all SSR.
Alternative Acquisition

GI: You’ll get one 4* character or R5 event weapon every patch at the very least. That aside, save up enough star dust to buy a stella fortuna and pray to rng or wait for a new area for prototypes I guess? Yeah, GI’s not very kind outside of the gacha. You need 7 copies of a character and 5 copies of a weapon in order to get their max potential.
HK3: All b-rank and a-rank characters can be farmed for their initial unlocks and subsequent upgrades, as well as some s-rank characters from different systems. However, characters need way more copies in order to reach max potential compared to Genshin; a-ranks need at least the equivalent of 20 extra copies and s-ranks 10 extra copies. The value you get each patch from GI’s gacha pulls is more or less equal to HK3’s gacha + farming, though HK3 is better since you can choose what you want to farm so you have more control. As for weapons, you can craft with relatively few restrictions some weapons of the highest rarity, and you only need one copy of a weapon for max effectiveness. Some weapons do have an upgraded form; only some of these can be farmed slowly and the materials you get for these upgrades is also limited without spending money.
ToT: Big events in ToT that happen every once or a month or so will either give a copy of an SR card or give you at least enough materials to get an upgrade to an SR card, and may also give 5 copies of one or more R cards. All card rarities require 5 total copies or 1 initial copy + 20 character universal upgrade materials for that rarity to fully upgrade. That aside, you can also farm fragments for select SR cards, with 100 fragments required to get a copy. You can still farm these after you max out upgrading and convert them into universal upgrade materials, so in the long enough run you can farm upgrades for all your SR cards (though you’ll probably have capped them before then).
Gacha Functionality

GI: 1.6% probability for a 5* character with a 90 pull pity, which is distributed as 0.6% before 75 and much higher afterwards. You’re only guaranteed the uprate every other 90 pull pity and when you’re not guaranteed you have a 50% chance for the uprate. Same thing for 4*’s with different rates and 3 uprates instead of one. Dupes of characters that are maxed out get converted into stardust which can be used to buy some things but most importantly for big spenders can be converted into fate refunds (though it really sucks to get a 5* dupe you’ve maxed out on). 1.85% probability for a 5* weapon with an 80 pull pity, which also has the soft pity system of lower rates than that up to a certain pull amount. There are 2 uprates and you’re only guaranteed a specific uprate every 3rd weapon if you select one, though you are guaranteed one of the 2 uprates every other weapon. Otherwise, it’s a 75% chance for the uprates. Same thing for the 4*’s with different rates and 5 uprates instead. There’s also the standard banner but nobody in their right mind pulls in that unless you truly want to gamble.
HK3: Character banners will only have a single available s-rank with a 1.5% probability and 100 pity, and this 1.5% probability is fixed throughout the pity unlike GI’s soft pity. From all the whales I talked to with thousands if not tens of thousands of pulls, this rate is actually higher in practice as well since they seem to average under 60 as opposed to the 66.66 expected value. ELF banners work in the same way. There’s also something called Advanced Supply that gives you a certain number of fragments when you reach a certain number of pulls, though pity does not carry over. There’s also a billion other special banner types with idiosyncrasies that I either don’t remember or never encountered. Dupe characters and ELFs are converted into fragments, and fragments for those you’ve maxed out can be exchanged for special currency that can be used to buy different things.
For equipment, there’s two main types. Expansion has a lower rate but has a 50 pity per piece of signature gear for a total of 200 pity to guarantee the entire set. Focused has a higher rate but nothing outside of a 10 guarantee for any high rarity equipment piece. I’m pretty sure there’s also a bunch of other weird special type banners here as well. There’s also the dorm character and equipment supply, but nobody in their right mind pulls in that unless you truly want to gamble.
ToT: ToT used to be the GOAT in terms of gacha, but we got the nerfed version. There are a billion types of banners that I already covered in my 1.3 update guide. What is important is that all of them at least have an SSR rate of 1.6% (some have 2%) and a pity of 100 (some are 90). All banners have multiple SSR in the pool; however, your pity does not reset if you pull an SSR you already own as long as there are other SSR in the pool you don’t own (or are otherwise not a designated special SSR). This means that if you pull in a banner where there are only 2 SSR and you own one, your pity for that card is guaranteed 100. On the other hand, if the banner has 4 SSR you all don’t own, it’s literally 400. The rate also works similarly to HK3 where it’s a flat amount instead of soft pity like GI. Importantly though, ToT has the best dupe system out of all the games. All post max R cards are worth 1/10th of a universal SR upgrade resource, while SR cards are worth 1 of them. You can use these upgrade resources for every SR, even special event ones. Same thing for SSR, except they are worth 2 universal SSR resource so each SSR is worth at worst half of any other SSR.
You know, now that I look at it, why the hell does miHoYo use different rarities systems in literally all of their games (GI-*, HK3-Alphabet, ToT-Rare) where is the consistency oi.
Gacha Dependency

GI: Seeing as I’ve literally gotten 36* in every abyss since 1.1/1.2 times (could’ve gotten it on the 3rd ever cycle if I weren’t busy being slave labored by miHoYo and too lazy to reset) and have been using the literal same team since 1.3 with the same artifacts (some of them literally have 4* or +0 for god’s sake) with only a few sparse talent upgrades since then even when the teams literally anti-synergize with the enemy composition in the floors, I think it’s safe to say there’s not exactly much gacha dependency. Look, actual good CC’s (not any of the ones you’re thinking of) can 36* with all 4* teams with 3* weapons and Keeby can literally stop by and do it when he’s bored without extensive knowledge. Fine, let’s assume you literally do not want to use your brain at all. You can literally stat check 33* if you’ve properly invested into any set-up. That comes out to literally a 50 primogem loss every cycle or a 1200 primogem loss over a year. That’s barely more than 1% of your total primogem income, so not exactly a big loss. In other words, the game is extremely non gacha dependent and you can pretty much pull what you want.
HK3: They’ve changed up Abyss to be less punitive since I’ve stopped playing from what I hear, but back in the day the difference between retaining Agony and Red Lotus was literally 160 crystals, twice a week. That came out to 1280 crystals a month, which meant you would bleed more premium currency in a month in HK3 for only being moderately competent than you would in GI in a year (which was also 10% if not more of your monthly income in HK3). Honkai has an extreme amount of specialization. Due to types, boss specifics, and weather, you pretty much run into the situation where you have 1-2 valks that are super good at something, 1-2 more valks that are still pretty good, and then you fall off a cliff if you use anybody else. And because both MA and Abyss are literally ranked, by definition a certain amount of the game population is going to be screwed by a certain amount every cycle as opposed to any moderate investment in GI getting you full rewards. While NA is giga pushover and you can occasionally max out rewards for everything completely F2P, you need both a decent amount of luck and Keeby level skill. And seeing as how there aren’t more Keebys lying around, that should tell you exactly how difficult that is. To sum up, HK3’s gacha dependency is pretty high and you’ll actually take big resource losses if you don’t have the proper investment.
ToT: Seeing as I pretty much cleared the hardest content in the game in a week in CBT, then went back and fully cleared the hardest content in the game actually 2 weeks into the actual launch, yeah this game is a complete pushover. You literally can pull exclusively for the card stories you want to read. Yeah there’s some more difficult content in events occasionally that require a certain amount of power, but those you can normally clear with weaker decks by spending more stamina. ToT’s also hard upper capped on power. All SSR’s have the same deck power (not the same effectiveness in combat mind you), so once you have 40 10/10/10 SSR’s you actually can’t increase your deck strength anymore and so miHoYo can’t increase difficulty any further than that without adding something new. C’mon, do you really think an otome game needs hard mathematics; it’s literally an otome game. (Well you can seeing as I’ve probably written 50+ pages of guides for it at this point but you really don’t need it).
Anyways, we’ll be wrapping up there. If there are any other portions of these games you have comparative questions on, I’ll do my best to address them. Though I really don’t want to make this thing another article series. Which city am I even on now again? Natlan? Snezhnaya? Daheck would I even name the series?


