Edit 1:What the hell, the post literally bugged out when I tried to include images. miHoYo for 1) I was joking about the shadowbanning (kind of not really), but why are my posts getting broken and 2) when are you guys going to fix this bug it's been here for like 20 years at this point.
Edit 2: It's literally freakin' Whiteblind that's imploding the post, I'm going to have to demote its recommendation section just for that.
Investment
Constellation
The two salient constellations are C2 and C6, more noticeably C6 than C2. Not to say any of his constellations are bad but the other effects may not be as noticeable. C1 pretty much just gives you 5 buff stacks during Itto’s burst and it’s most effective in tandem with C6 when 5 buff stacks are worth more than 5 buff stacks. Otherwise, it’ll let you start swinging more immediately in combination with Ushi rather than doing a few autos, but it’ll also leave you in the awkward situation where your first set of swings eat up a weird amount of burst duration rather than a more even 2 sets of swings you’d otherwise do during burst.
C2 is more important for the energy than it is for the cd, because let’s be real aint no way you fitting all your support rotations into 2.5s that’s 4-5s at least. If Yoimiya’s idle time is short enough that you may not need cd reduction depending on support rotation and player preference, then Itto with a 1s longer duration and burst animation needs it even less. However, knocking off 18 energy is more than a fourth of your energy requirements. That’s literally better refund than Venti A2, which otherwise refunds the most. You’ll be much less likely to run into the situation of not having enough energy for burst and thus awkwardly waiting for cds while doing 0 damage that you might be familiar with if you've ever played Xiao. This also frees you up from needing to worry about ER stats on Itto.
C4 you can think of as a more conditional Raiden C4, since it’s a smaller increase but on multiple stats and it works on Itto himself. That being said, the only characters where atk and def simultaneously get full value are Noelle and Itto, and since they’re both on-field DPS they can’t simultaneously make use of the buff in the first place. Itto himself can make use of part of the atk increase and can snapshot the entire def increase. That being said, Itto’s drowning in def from a billion different sources and thus drowning in atk as a result, so the additional effect of C4 is diminished. Aside from him, Albedo has alternative split scaling so functionally speaking he only gets the equivalent of a 20% stat buff for all his damage. Gorou really only scales on def (not that he does much damage anyways), so he doesn’t get maximum utilization from the buff either. And anyone else would really only scale on attack. So it’s a decent buff to the party but probably not salient enough to be noticeable in real combat.
Now then, C6 is by far the strongest constellation in Itto. You can frankly consider it stronger than the rest of his constellations put together and not because the other three are pushover weak. One, it gives overwhelming stat advantage. It’s literally 70 cdmg you know? That’s equivalent to a 35% crit rate increase, and last time I checked nobody has that in any passive. With Redhorn and Gorou C6, Itto can clear 100/250 on his charged attacks with only moderate investment. Which might be fine since it’s localized only to his specialized charged attack. Except C6 also increases the damage distribution of said charged attack by making each stack of his buff worth twice as many attacks in expected value. The actual math is more complicated than that in terms of the distribution of attacks, but instead of 5 stacks giving you 5 attacks you can expect it to give you around 10 instead. Keep in mind that due to Itto’s A1, each attack past the 3rd makes the entire chain more efficient due to the atk spd bonus. In tandem with his C1 and Ushi stack generatio, Itto can remain at full stacks for a good ~5s before the rng starts kicking in. If you high roll enough, you’ll actually run out of his burst state before your charged attack chain finishes which is quite hilarious to say the least.
Artifacts

Husk of Opulent Dreams, duh. You really thought miHoYo would release a set in the same patch for a character and it wouldn’t be his best set? Let’s take the best alternative option for increased damage, Shimenawa, and compare. The 24% geo dmg% is worth more than the 24% type dmg%, since Ushi is also a nuclear missile. The atk% is worth less than the def% since he’ll have more base def than base atk. Let’s be generous and say it cancels out 15% def and leaves him with 39% def. For 26% type damage to outscale 39% def, he’ll need 1.5 times the total additional def as dmg%. From all sources, Itto will have ~100% dmg% at least, meaning he needs 150% additional def. Between a def% timepiece, R5 Redhorn, and a maxed out Gorou he’ll exceed that amount by a slight margin.

So yeah, if you’re really going for the min-max on damage on the very high end of things, you could run Shimenawa. Good luck having the proper elemental skill rotation and energy management for that if you do though.
Weapons

Redhorn Stonethresher, duh. You really thought anything changed in the last 2 paragraphs that would make the 5* weapon released alongside the character not be his best weapon? The def% value is above conversion efficiency, the scaling addition is a 20% true damage increase on his charged attacks at worst for R5, the substat let’s him get inflated crit stats and he doesn’t care about low base attack.
Aside from Redhorn, all the other 5*’s kinda meme. You don’t attack out of burst and you don’t ever willingly want to normal attack for Pine. You get poor scaling from atk% for Unforged and Gravestone is still a support weapon with even worse mileage. Pride is slightly alright. Dmg% is the stat Itto has the least dilution on and ER will help with burst comfort. That being said, those vacuum blades put together probably won’t even out damage the Ushi nuclear missile, so you aren’t getting much mileage from that half of the affix.

You’re better off just using Serpent Spine if you don’t have Redhorn, since it gives dmg%. Better have a proper shield or kill the enemies quickly though, since when you’re whaling on them (figuratively with your wallet and literally with your big stick) you can’t exactly avoid their attacks otherwise. If you don’t have Spine, you can also use Whiteblind, though you are going to be def% diluted to the moon.
That aside, Blackcliff is also usable if fighting groups (though not as effective as on other characters since atk% has lower mileage) and Lithic at R5 if you have 3 Liyue teammates just for the crit (which means it’ll probably never be usable since good luck getting a viable composition under those constraints). Every other weapon either has a low mileage/useless substat/affix, so don’t even consider it.
Conclusion
If you don’t have a C6 Noelle and want a melee geo main DPS, then you can pull for Itto. If you have a C6 Noelle and for some reason want another one that’s more restrictive and conditionally better at certain things, you can also pull for him. If you’re rich af and want to have the experience of beating things to a mush (because if you try that irl you’ll get sent to jail) while playing the gacha that you seem to love given how much you have to do that for C6 like you would with Eula C6 except you’re not screwed if that single hit doesn’t crit/misses, then you can also pull for Itto. Otherwise, unless you want to cosplay your intelligence irl in-game by running at people with a big stick and yelling, I can’t see any other reason.
For other character spot analysis, go to Sumeru Studies™.


