Post Details Page

[Version 2.3] 2.3 New Weapon Analysis

Only 2 new weapons this patch, one of which being an event weapon, both of which being hyper specialized so pretty easy to evaluate.  


Let’s start with the 5*.

Redhorn Stonethresher

Scales to 56% and 80%.


Redhorn is actually relatively above efficiency on its affix values, seeing as the equivalent of 20% ATK% is 24% DEF% and the most efficient additional damage affix is Crescent Pike at only 40% of ATK, not to mention Redhorn’s additional damage benefits from more DMG% multipliers because it’s considered part of the normal/charged attack.  That being said, both of its values are DEF which most characters don’t have a lot of.  That being said, it also has 88.2% CDMG, which is extremely useful if you’re lower on the artifact investment spectrum.  That being said, it also is a Type 44 5* and that 542 base attack is kind of relevant for most characters.


At this point I swear miHoYo has something against claymore characters, since the first CRIT/CDMG claymore they release has poor affix efficiency for most of them.  It’s actually extremely annoying to compare to the rest of the 5* claymores as well, since it has an extremely good general use offensive substat but a super niche affix.  It’s just better on stat efficiency for some characters when you’re on the low end of investment, but it doesn’t synergize with most people directly.  Pine and Pride also have normal attack focus but for different things and Unforged is a stat stick but for different stats.  Gravestone is still a support weapon.  At the end of the day, whether Redhorn is better than existing options depends not only on the character’s DEF and damage profile but also investment.


For specific users:

Itto/Noelle: As the two Claymores who actually scale off of DEF, this weapon is naturally better than existing options for them.  After all, their low base ATK means Unforged/Gravestone gets poor efficiency, nor do they do physical damage for Pine/Pride.  Assuming you have 150% total DEF% bonus on Noelle (on the lower end) and have maxed out basic attack and burst (lvl11/13), a R1 Redhorn is a true ~12.5% or 1/8 damage increase on normal attacks for her (and probably closer to 20% in practice).  This value gets better the more DEF% you have (to dilute your flat ATK value before conversion) and lower investment your skills are, not to mention on charged attacks which at certain DEF%/Redhorn Refinement levels will actually out damage normals.  It’s even better on Itto because his base DEF is comparatively higher than his flat ATK and he gets a lower conversion ratio from his burst than Noelle.  Both of them also get the majority of their damage from normal/charged attacks, meaning increased damage on those are high efficiency.


Xinyan: If you run her Main DPS with C6 on charged attacks, she gets better efficiency on the DEF%.  That being said, the low base attack is a concern since her ATK% ratio on her charged attacks exceeds her DEF% ratio and even with DEF% having higher numbers, ATK% still gets better scaling at high skill levels.  Unless you also have super high Redhorn refinement, in which case DEF gets slightly better value.  That being said, she still has her E+Q, so if you have good investment the Unforged will just out stat stick it.  On the other hand, she gets good mileage from the weapon if used as an E+Q support as her C2 means she gets extreme efficiency on the CDMG substat and the DEF% increases her shielding, though it lacks the inherent support ability of other weapons.


Everyone Else: For everyone else, well they don’t have anything near that level of DEF efficiency.  Even with a R5 Redhorn, they’re unlikely to get more than half of their ATK as DEF, so the comparative additive value of the affix is not as high.  That being said, if they normal/charged attack enough and/or are low enough offensive stat investment, it’s still a passable choice, though I wouldn’t recommend it over the other options as it has no support ability and will eventually get outscaled with enough investment, especially if both weapons are refined since Redhorn’s substat’s weight out of the total weapon effectiveness decreases.  


Verdict: If you’re planning on using Itto/Noelle, then Redhorn is a good option.  You can also get it if you plan on using Xinyan, though it’s comparable to existing options and if you already have one of them, there’s not much reason to get Redhorn in addition.  Aside from that, if you’re looking to get a stat stick weapon, this isn’t the one and you should wait for a more generally usable CRIT/CDMG claymore to be released.


Cinnabar Spindle

Scales to 80%


miHoYo, I can’t decide if you hate Albedo or you love Albedo.  On one hand, you half trolled him with his scaling and mechanical distribution, not to mention his flower getting boomed super easily by a bunch of things.  On the other hand, you gave him an event weapon, and when it turned out that one was generally usable and there were better options for him, you literally gave him another one except you straight tailored it for him.  Seriously, you may as well call it “Albedo’s Sword” at this point.


I don’t even think I need this section at this point, but w/e for specific character users:


Albedo: This weapon is made for Albedo, but it’s made in a way that miHoYo has given up on high mechanical execution Albedo and just wants you to play him as a literal flower bot.  For optimal Albedo mechanics, you want to cast your flower, create 3 explosions, then immediately recast your flower to reset the explosion CD and thus increase the frequency of explosions.  This along with using your burst whenever it’s up.  If you play Albedo like this, then his DEF vs. ATK skill ratio is actually around 55% to 45%.  Thus, Cinnabar’s DEF% doesn’t get as much value, and because of the explosion reset timing, you only get the affix on 2 out of every 3 explosions.  This changes his distribution to 60% to 40% at best, so not much movement.  

On the other hand, if you literally plop your flower, let’s say, every 24s and only use your burst every 24s as well, then you’re looking more at a 80% to 20% ratio or something along those lines.  Then the DEF% is enhancing a larger proportion of his damage, and he’s gaining about a 30% damage increase to 80% of his damage at worst.  In this case, this weapon has much greater effectiveness.


Everyone Else: Nobody else gets much mileage from DEF, nor do they have skills that can make full use of the affix.  The closest is like Bennett on his burst or Qiqi’s E, and they’d pretty much prefer anything over this.  


Verdict: This is literally how miHoYo is telling you to roll for Albedo and roll for his C2 while you’re at it.  


miHoYo, can you for the love of god please release a general use CRIT/CDMG claymore and make more general use event weapons?  Or at least have more stable prototype sources with more generally usable craftable weapons.  I’m out here about to get 10 The Bells and not a single copy of the 4* weapon I actually need.


For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.

Genshin Impact • Guides & Analyses
Guides & Walkthroughs
Resource Planning
Instructions for Newcomers
304
15
20
304
0
All comments 15

Loading...

All Tools

Recommended Users