Post Details Page

[Version 2.4] 2.4 Character Rundown Shenhe Part 1

How does Liyue’s exorcist families (actually I guess it’s just one family seeing as Shenhe is Chongyun’s aunt) have so many special exorcising talents, but they still so incompetent that Xiao is the one who has to clean house on all the evil stuff all the time.

Table of Contents

Introduction

Talents

Constellations

Role

Investment

Conclusion

Introduction

Shenhe is a cryo polearm who is also a cryo support character.  If I had a penny for every cryo polearm character who was a support, I’d have two pennies which isn’t a lot but it’s kinda weird that both cryo polearms are skewed in that direction.  As compared to Rosaria though, Shenhe is way more indexed for support and way more for cryo.

Talents

Normal Attack: Shenhe has a 5-sequence normal attack chain that you will never use.  Her charged attack is the forward tunneling version you will also never use.  

Elemental Skill: Shenhe’s elemental skill has a tap version and a hold version.  Both versions will buff the entire party with Icy Quill.  The tap version has her dash forward.  10s CD, generates 3 particles, generates 5 stacks of Icy Quill with 10s duration.  The hold version has her deal damage in an AoE circle around her while shifting back.  15s CD, generates 4 particles, generates 7 stacks of Icy Quill with 15s duration.

As for Icy Quill, all party members are granted this buff separately with independent stack consumption.  (Well, it’s technically a quota but it’s easier to think of it as stacks, so I’m doing that moving forward).  When any character-sourced cryo damage hits an enemy, it deals additional damage based on Shenhe’s attack, but everything else scales based on the triggering character’s stats.  It’s still one total instance of damage though, so you can think of it adding to the trigger attack’s skill ratio, but indexed off Shenhe’s attack.  When one instance of damage hits multiple enemies, multiple stacks of Icy Quill are consumed.  This buff is kind of a hassle to explain briefly, so go see the end of the section example if you’re still confused.  

Elemental Burst: Shenhe does AoE cryo damage and then creates a field.  Enemies in the field have their cryo and physical RES reduced based on skill level up to 15%, and will take 2 instances of cryo damage every 2s.  The field lasts for 12s for 6 cycles (12 hits) of damage.  Is an 80/20 burst.  

A1: Active characters in Shenhe’s burst field gain 15% Cryo DMG%.

A2: Tap Skill increases Elemental Skill/Burst DMG% by 15% for 10s for the whole party.  Hold Skill increases Normal/Charged/Plunging DMG% by 15% for 15s for the whole party.

Passive: Your 20hr expeditions in Liyue get 25% more materials oi this is literally worse than the time reduction one for all cases except if you only dispatch a 20hr expedition a day you w0t miHoYo. 


Example: Let’s assume you have a party with Shenhe, Ayaka, and like Kaeya I guess.  Shenhe has 4000 ATK and the other two both have 2000 ATK.  Shenhe uses her tap skill, giving all party members 5 stacks of Icy Quill.  You swap to Ayaka, and use a normal attack into a charged attack combo against two enemies.  The normal attack whiffs on both of them, but the charged attack is homing so all three hits land on both of them.  For every enhanced charged attack, the damage dealt is:

((Ayaka’s ATK(2000) * Ayaka’s Charged Attack Ratio * Anything that specifically only modifies Ayaka’s Charged Attack Ratio) + (Shenhe’s ATK(4000) * Icy Quill Skill Ratio)) * Any of Ayaka’s offensive stats that modify her Charged Attack * Enemy damage modification

Since Ayaka’s charged attack hits three times, Icy Quill applies to each hit for a total of 6 stack consumption.  Or so it would, if Ayaka didn’t only have 5 stacks.  As such, the third hit of her charged attack will only gain Icy Quill’s additional damage on one enemy, and the other attack will be unmodified.  After finishing this sequence, Ayaka has 0 Icy Quill stacks, but both Shenhe and Kaeya will still have 5 stacks that will remain until used as well or when they expire after 10s.  

Constellations

C1: Elemental skill gains an additional charge.

C2: Elemental Burst lasts for an additional 6s and active characters in the field additionally gain 15% Cryo CRIT DMG%.  

C4: When characters trigger Icy Quill’s effect, Shenhe gains 5% DMG on her next Elemental Skill cast per stack, up to 50 stacks which are consumed on cast.  

C6: Icy Quill stacks are not consumed for Normal and Charged attacks.

Role Breakdown

Cryo Support (C0; C2+ preferred) 

Haaaaaaaaaaah, I have a lot I want to say but miHoYo hasn’t listened to my feedback in an extremely long time and also this kind of stuff is no longer my responsibility, so let’s just get on with the analysis going forward.


Shenhe is a cryo support.  Specifically, if you want her to actually be effective, she’s a cryo support for cryo heavy compositions, and in most cases, against single enemies.  If you’re trying to run her as a physical support due to her burst and A2, Xinyan’s buffs are better in most cases for that purpose.  And if you’re just aiming for a general cryo support unit with mild cryo application, you might as well just pull Ganyu next banner.  She has wider range/better uptime and almost just as many support skills at C6 as Shenhe at C6, not to mention she actually can be used to do damage.  Shenhe ends up being super tailored as a result of her kit.


The primary reason behind Shenhe’s narrow placement is a combination of three relevant factors: her support skills, her damage, and Icy Quill.  Let’s touch on those in that order.  Shenhe has many support abilities, and aside from the Physical Res Down and Type DMG%, the rest only apply to Cryo.  The buffs independently are actually on the weaker side (Res Down weaker than Eula, A1 lower than Ganyu’s A2 with worse downtime and smaller coverage range miHoYo you w0t), but taken in totality they’re relatively potent.  15% Cryo DMG%, 15% Cryo CRIT DMG% (C2), 15% Cryo Res Down, and 15% Type DMG% along with Icy Quills that can only trigger from Cryo.  That’s around half the value as Bennett’s buff, so all-in-all not bad.


…Or so it would be if the rest of her value wasn’t almost entirely dependent on Icy Quill.  She doesn’t do well as a main DPS even with Chongyun infusing her autos.  Her Elemental Skill outside of Icy Quill has very poor damage scaling and isn’t great on energy.  Seems like miHoYo doesn’t hate Xiao as much as I thought, since her tap E is just his but with worse damage and same energy without the buff.  (On second thought, they released another spear that doesn’t really help him at all on the same patch he’s getting a rerun, so yeah actually they do hate Xiao).  Her burst without C2 barely out-damages Diona’s, and even with C2 extension it’s not even 2/3 and 3/4 of Kaeya’s non-extended burst and Rosaria’s extended burst damage, respectively.  


That’s not necessarily a problem, since that’s what Icy Quill is for.  She does give some support to the team after all, so if her damage is passable all things considered, that still works.  The thing about Icy Quill is that it can either be godly absurd or absolute garbage, and frankly it’s more dependent on situation than team composition.  Because Icy Quill is consumed when any attack hits any enemy, even if the same attack hits multiple enemies, it’s way more effective when you're fighting solo than against groups.  Fight one enemy and it may net you a large damage increase; fight a big group and it might as well not exist.  If you actually want Icy Quill and by extension Shenhe’s damage contribution to not be a meme, you’re pretty much limited to fighting single enemies (two might be passable as well).


Outside of how Icy Quill is consumed, the other aspect that affects its effectiveness is its mechanism.  Icy Quill’s base damage is dependent on Shenhe’s ATK, but its amplification is dependent on the triggering character’s stats and the trigger attack.  Furthermore, its damage is added onto the trigger attack rather than being a separate instance of damage, so it won’t interfere with reactions as a result.  This then results in an interesting dynamic; the more indexed in ATK Shenhe is, the worse her offensive stat distribution is, but the stronger Icy Quill is for other party members comparatively as they maintain a good offensive stat distribution but with larger attack on those triggers.


Also it’s not like you’re entirely sacking your damage on Shenhe if you go full into ATK.  Assuming you have CRIT%/ATK%/CDMG% splits of 75%/112.5%/150%, then going 337.5% into ATK%, which is the equivalent value in stats, is only a ~3% damage loss.  Though, the poor distribution affects all of Shenhe’s damage (as low as her E+Q are in damage, they still do count), while the increased benefit in ATK% only affects Icy Quill triggers, both from Shenhe and other party members.  Thus, the more members of the party that can trigger Icy Quill AKA functionally the number of cryo party members, the higher value stacking ATK% and sacking her other stats gets.


Well then, let’s assume you run a 4 Cryo composition then to make maximum use of Icy Quill and support abilities (though I guess you could have Chongyun to force procs on other elements, but then you’re not getting any Cryo DMG% bonus and you’ll have to basic attack on them, so doesn’t seem very functional).  Well, your only 2 healer options are Diona and Qiqi.  You want to run them full DPS in order to get max benefit from Shenhe’s ATK% stacking on Quill?  That… actually sounds mildly feasible, albeit somewhat hilarious.  That being said, it’s actually more efficient on artifact stats if you have 3 Cryo’s and 1 Hydro for Blizzard Strayer, not to mention nobody is wearing support sets in that case.  Also, even though Shenhe prefers as many Cryo’s as possible so she can entirely sack ER and only have ATK%, having 4 in the party is probably a little overkill.  


As an alternative, you could run one Hydro in the party along with Shenhe and two offensive Cryo units.  Kokomi and Barbara are both healers; Kokomi being the more efficient one since she can literally just swap in once every 20s to be a jellyfish bot and can proc Millelith compared to Barbara being not nearly as hands off.  Shenhe can pull around ~1.5x the amount of ATK of an otherwise properly built character, so the Quills are getting extreme value on two units as well as being passable on Shenhe herself.  Alternatively, if things are frozen they shouldn’t be able to kill you, so you could also just run an offensive option like Xingqiu or Mona.  


Drop the number of Cryo units any further, and there’s not much of a difference between Shenhe ATK% stacking and distributing offensive stats more optimally on herself instead.  At this point her support ability is also losing value, since there’s fewer people to make use of her predominantly Cryo support, seeing as if you’re just talking about her A2 amplification you might as well just have brought Thoma’s C6/Raiden instead.  Well, all things considered, if you factor in the total Quill damage from the party on top of Shenhe’s damage otherwise, it’s still alright in a party of 2 Cryo’s, though you’re not really getting more mileage than if you just had a Kaeya/Rosaria instead and it may not be worth the hassle to bother.  Not to mention, at this point you’ll actually have a hard time maintaining burst without ER, so your ability to distribute solely into offensive stats will fall.


All of that’s assuming again that you’re only facing a single enemy, because even if you have 4 Cryo units, if you’re fighting something like 10 enemies those Quills still might as well be useless.  And all your units need to be able to proc all the Quills at the required frequency, though that’s not super hard.  Thus, you’ll get large mileage from both Shenhe’s support and Quill damage in Cryo skewed compositions against few enemies even with Shenhe’s own comparative damage deficiency taken into account.  Outside of that, however, she doesn’t have much use that someone else won’t just do better.  I’ll address her C6 functionality changes in the constellation section next.


Continue to Part 2


For other character spot analysis, go to Sumeru Studies™

Genshin Impact • Guides & Analyses
Guides & Walkthroughs
Character Review
Shenhe
512
24
41
512
0
All comments 24

Loading...

All Tools

Recommended Users