EDIT: How come it's been 200 patches since I reported the issue to you all in management but you still haven't fixed the picture bug it's almost like you're not trying and don't actually particularly care about the state of things, hm?
Investment
Constellation
Ayato’s like Yae in that while all his Constellations are somewhat alright, if you’re going to go all in on the Elemental Skill train you might as well go all the way in since his C6 gives him the biggest enhancement. Regardless, they don’t add any other utility or let him effectively operate in other roles, so you’re going all in on his Skill damage here.
His C1 is better than the older HP% threshold enhancements, but that’s just because those are extremely weak at this point and his is functionally 20% DMG% at best, which is decent at best. It gets even lower effectiveness depending on your set-up, because Ayato is liable to get DMG% diluted. Depending on his weapons or artifacts, you might be looking at somewhere close to 100% to 150% DMG% bonus already, so the value added here is even lower.
His C2 tacks on an extra buff stack on each attack at best if his A1 works properly and at worst is number of attacks minus 3. It will add more stacks than A1 per Skill rotation, but A1 doesn’t give the largest damage increase so C2 is similar. The Max HP% is also for increasing damage dealt, so that bumps up the damage increase C2 gives, though it’s still nothing overwhelming. If something was going to kill you anyways it’s still probably killing you even with C2, so don’t be getting it to rely on saving your skin.
C4 might look like it adds support utility, but again since nobody in his party is really going to be normal attacking except him and he can’t really function as an independent support, its primary benefit is going to be the attacks it adds for him. Without any other ATK SPD increases, it’ll take him to 18 slashes at most. That’s pretty good if you were only able to get 15 slashes, since that’s a 20% effective damage increase on his skill. On the other hand, if you could get 16 before, it’s a more muted 12.5%, and it’s less effective the more other ATK SPD sources you have.
As for C6, this thing adds on a ~30% effective damage increase at worst with the highest skill ratios and has the added benefit of helping ensure Hydro ends up as the base at the start of Ayato’s buff. It’s a similar nuke as Ayaka’s C6, except Ayato’s C6 scales with DMG% multipliers as they are additional normal attacks. Thus, they get the full benefit of Ayato’s build and hit like a truck.
Artifacts
What artifact set Ayato wants to use depends on his stat distribution. You might consider using a DMG% set, Blizzard Strayer, or Echoes of an Offering in different circumstances. Let’s start with Echoes, since that one is clearly made for him. Echoes has an expected value of triggering half of the total hits than can trigger it, which aside from Ayato’s C6 all of his slashes are spread far apart to be able to. It has a weird meme distribution, but should even out across the larger number of hits Ayato is doing. Even taking into account his C6 and highest skill ratios, Echoes should still be around a 15% effective damage increase on the 4-set and at least a 20-25% increase for most people. Echoes is thus dependent on skill ratio, since it scales off the same stats as the rest of Ayato’s buffed attacks and thus the lower your skill values, the stronger it is.
Moving onto Blizzard Strayer, you can only use this set if Ayato is in a freeze composition. If he is, then the set is giving him 40% CRIT, which is more effective the lower stat distribution into those stats he has. For example, if he currently has 80/160, then converting the 40% extra CRIT to give him 100/200 is slightly more than a 30% effective damage increase. On the other hand, if he’s already 100/200, then converting that over to 100/280 is only slightly more than 25% effective damage increase. Blizzard is thus dependent on the level of investment you currently have into Ayato’s CRIT stats. He also doesn’t get use out of the 2-set compared to the other sets, though generally ATK% is more readily available than CRIT.
As for the DMG% sets, the 3 different sets are Gladiator’s Finale, Heart of Depth, and Shimenawa's Reminiscence. There isn’t much difference between the first two, while Shimenawa is stronger, but you might as well kiss your Burst goodbye even more than it already is if you use that set. The strength of these sets depends on the amount of DMG% you already have. For example, if you have no other sources of DMG%, then Shimenawa is giving you a 50% effective damage increase. If you already have 100% DMG% elsewhere, that value drops to 25%. Thus, the DMG% sets are dependent on the investment you currently have into Ayato’s DMG% stats.
As such, you’re pretty much picking sets based on your weakest stat, Echoes for lower skill values, Blizzard for lower CRIT values, and a DMG% set at lower DMG% values.
Weapons
I don’t even think I need to say that the rule of 5*’s released with the character being the optimal weapon still applies, but yes it still applies. Thus, Haran Geppaku Futsu is obviously the best weapon for him. That thing is up to 104% DMG% on all of his relevant damage and also extremely easy to trigger, since you’re almost certainly guaranteed to use 2 elemental skills in his downtime.
Aside from that, you also have several different other 5* options. Jade Cutter is the other best option, since Ayato might actually have above average HP (C2) and also actually does kind of scale off of HP. Mistsplitter is also decent on him since he can easily trigger the damage from Normal Attack and you can be sure his energy will be dead, though he’ll only be able to keep the 3rd stack up 50% uptime on his relevant damage at best. Summit Shaper is a decent stat-stick if you have a shield. Skyward Blade is also mildly workable since it does increase ATK SPD and helps charge your burst, though it’s not great and there are better options. Don’t use the other two 5* though; they’re missing an entire substat.
As for 4* swords, the ideal option is Black Sword. It has a CRIT stat substat and Black Sword’s affix efficacy is pretty self-explanatory since it boosts his relevant damage. Blackcliff is also good if you’re fighting groups of enemies so you can stack the affix. There are some decent options aside from that. The Flute is usable since you attack a lot, though Ayato hits around once every 0.4s or so, so it doesn’t line up the best with the affix. Amenoma helps with his energy problem, though his Elemental Skill CD is relatively long and thus doesn’t get the best value. Lion’s Roar can be used if Ayato is in an Electro-charged composition; otherwise, he can’t use the affix. Royal is another stat stick but loses value with more CRIT stats, which Ayato will almost certainly have much of. Everything aside from that’s going to be missing at least 1/3rd of the weapon, making them poor choices.
That aside, don’t you dare use any of the ER weapons. Sure, they’ll help him charge his burst, but then he’ll do no damage, so you’ll be putting the cart before the horse. Besides, the only one that really works is Favonius, and good luck doing damage without an offensive substat or affix.
Conclusion
If you want a high damage on-field Hydro applier that has fixed downtime, then pull for Ayato. If you’re a fan of Otto Apocalypse or Artem Wing (CN voice), then I don’t know actually can you guys really tell I can’t tbh unless I listen pretty closely. If you wanted to reunite a certain pair of siblings, well this is the wrong pair you’ll have to wait like 5 more years for the other pair probably at least. That aside, if you were planning on cosplaying Mahouka in-game, well now you can’t so instead of pulling this is where you go complain in the version feedback.
For other character spot analysis, go to Sumeru Studies™


