Well, now that there’s a weapon pity (albeit not amazing but still more impactful than you might realize; more on that in another article) you can somewhat target specific weapons now as long as you save up 240 pulls worth of primogems for the worst case scenario on one of those banners. I still don’t particularly recommend it unless you spend a relatively good amount since the max required pulls and average required pulls are still both higher than for a featured character. Also 240 pulls is like 4 patches worth of savings give or take aka literally 6 months to potentially end up getting only 3 5* weapons, 2 of which you might not like or want. And if you don’t save up that much, well then you’re back to actually gambling since the pity doesn’t carry across banners. With that being said, let’s take a look at the new weapons.
Introduction
Before we talk about specifics, we’re first going to need to set some general rules/baselines about weapons. You can do all the math you want but unless your math matches your in-game situation perfectly (which I guarantee it won’t) it’ll only serve as a situational reference, which you can get at pretty much the same effectiveness without all the complicated formulas.
1. The fewer resources you have, the more relevant the substat is compared to the affix. 5* weapon affixes tend to generally follow a pattern where they have 2 scaling effects on their affixes: an unconditional stat passive and some conditional/active part. The unconditional stats tend to scale to approximately slightly less than a low-end substat value (unless you’re skyward blade and miHoYo hates you) at R5; for example, Skyward Harp has the highest crit dmg% affix at 40%, which is lower than Mistsplitters crit dmg% substat at 90 of 44.1% despite Mistsplitter being a Type 48 base attack and thus having low substat scaling due to high base attack. The conditional/active part generally tends to scale higher the more conditional/harder it is to use and has a lot of variance. As a general rule of thumb, the two put together at R1 have approximately the same weight as the substat and since generally these values double at R5 then at that point they’ll outweigh it by a factor of 2:1. Since most players are not whales, that means you’ll need to place importance on both the substat and the affix while the higher the refinement you can acquire, the less relevant the substat is compared to the affix.
2. The fewer resources you have, the better low base attack weapons are and vice versa. The lower base attack and higher substat value means that you’ll have an easier time balancing stats for optimal damage distribution. You approximately want to have a 1:1.5:2 ratio between crit%:bonus atk as a percentage of base atk:crit dmg% give or take. That’s bonus attack from all sources, not just atk%. The lower your base attack, the more bonus attack the feather accounts for relative to your base attack and the larger your substat value so you’re not as artifact substat dependent. A higher base attack weapon generally tends to outscale a lower base attack weapon in returns at ~100% atk% give or take. However, if you have 100% atk%, just including your feather flat attack you’re looking at something like ~130% bonus attack, meaning if you want balanced stats you’re going to need ~85% crit and ~170% crit damage. If you don’t have any external sources like from character/weapon/artifact abilities and are only relying on character ascension/weapon substat/artifact stats that’s a lot of investment or luck (probably both) that you’ll need to hit that. Not to say you’ll necessarily do less damage if your stats are less balanced than more balanced, but you’ll need more stats total to make up for it (like how rectangles can enclose larger areas than squares, as long as you have more fencing for the rectangle if you remember your middle school math classes.)
(Had an example section but then this post was too long LOL I'll add that as an adendum to the end of the craftable 4* section later).
5* Gacha
Since the majority of players aren’t megaladons, you’ll most likely be working with R1 5* weapons so any comparisons should center around that.
Mistsplitter Reforged

Scales to 24% and 16/32/56% at R5.
Mistsplitter is very clearly an elemental damage focused weapon seeing as it has an offensive substat and its affix only amplifies elemental damage. As such, the direct competitors for this weapon are Summit Shaper and Jade Cutter. Aquila is obviously a physical damage focused weapon due to its substat and Skyward Blade, outside of not actually being a real weapon that exists ISTG miHoYo buff this thing, is geared towards characters who need their bursts and have short cd bursts and are also physical based auto-attackers which is a mythical unicorn I don’t think exists (or just use the base attack and ER substat; either way not what Mistplitter does). Freedom sworn is a support weapon and although it can be used for straight DPS, it’ll almost certainly perform worse due to a combination of its substat, lower numbers, downtime, and more restrictive amplification.
At R1, Jade Cutter is probably getting you ~250 atk since that’s its approximate value with a max flower, its own 20% hp and some substats. That’s give or take equivalent to around ~30-33% atk% value. Summit Shaper gives you 40% atk%, so it’ll give slightly more value in most cases, but you need a shield and you need to stack it. Mistsplitter gives 40% elemental dmg% but only if all three stacks are active. Since every character has a feather which contributes to their attack being diluted, typically dmg% of the same amount is more effective than atk% (about 4/3 as effective if the amount from other sources is equal) especially since attack sources from elsewhere are more abundant than dmg%. If even one stack falls off it drops to 28% which is almost certainly weaker. Mistsplitter and Jade also have crit dmg/crit as their substat so their stat balancing is easier compared to Summit. Thus, in optimal situations Mistsplitter would give the highest increase but only if you can stably maintain all three stacks as opposed to Jade’s unconditional attack. Also Jade and Summit do have some defense utility so they’re slightly more comfortable to use in combat.
As for character specific users:
Ayaka: Even though this is supposed to be her signature weapon, Ayaka actually can’t maintain all three stacks more than 50% uptime due to her 20s burst cd. Luckily, miHoYo did false advertising and Ayaka’s actually a burst character who has ~50% of her damage profile in her burst which can get all three stacks so technically 75% of her damage can have all three stacks. Ayaka gets lost value on Jade Cutter since she'll already be at 60% crit due to Blizzard Strayer + Cryo resonance + base 5% so she’d have crit overflow just from that. She actually can use Summit Shaper as long as she brings Diona, which you can bring anyways for energy battery and for your healing slot. However, she does clash with every other shield generator in the game due to their removal of frozen. Due to Ayaka’s ascension giving crit dmg and the crit rate from her artifacts + resonance, there’s actually some situations where having an atk% mask is better than crit dmg, so Summit’s substat is also less of a liability. Overall, you’ll still do more damage with Mistsplitter in most scenarios, but it’d only be a marginal increase compared to Summit with Diona so you’re going to have to ask yourself if the payout is worth rolling for another 5* weapon.
Albedo: Actually pretty good since elemental dmg% applies to all of his damage since def scaling makes up at least 50% of his damage profile (probably more like 2/3 in practical use) and his e snapshots so as long as you don’t replace the one with higher stacks with lower stacks then the higher application can retain for up to 30s if you wish. That being said, he can’t get 3 stacks because his attacks don’t do elemental damage… unless you have a Chongyun/C6 Bennett in your party as well. Certainly much better than the other 2 5*’s, though all I’m going to say is an R5 HoD is easier to use and also a few hundred dollars cheaper.
Bennett: If you’re going for maximum attack increase from Bennett burst, well this is certainly better than the other option of Aquila since its substat + half of its affix are pretty much useless on him. I have other concerns if you’re pulling a 5* weapon just to make your amplification support that’s not a large part of the team’s damage profile do more damage but whatever makes you happy. That aside, if you play Bennett main DPS, then this weapon is also the best 5* on him since he’s extremely atk diluted due to his burst. Your issue in that case is actually worrying about the third condition for a stack. Since Bennett generates 1 particle/s on his burst, in 10s that’s 10 particles and since Bennett’s ascension passive is ER that means he’s getting at least about 40 energy there. If your ER is too high or too many enemies die in that time frame you can easily fill up your burst in which case you’ll lose a stack. I’m not sure how many people either of these situations apply to but in either case this weapon is a substantial boost for him.
Jean: She also can’t get 1 stack without external infusion, also her healing scales off of attack. Sure, you might get a marginal damage increase compared to another offensive weapon, but you’re getting less attack than Aquilla, Summit, and probably even Jade depending on your HP, not to mention you don’t have the support ability of Freedom-sworn. So sure, if you’re at the point where you don’t need either for her go ahead, but if you’re at that point you’ll have multiple R5 copies lying around anyways.
Kazuha: For most of you Kazuha’s a support character who builds solely EM and just does damage off of elemental reactions since you don’t have enough substat scaling to make him work otherwise. On the other hand, if you’re a whale and have him C6, then for strictly offensive purposes this weapon is better than Freedom-Sworn. Kazuha’s the only character who benefits doubly from this weapon’s first part of the affix, since he has elemental infusion, meaning it’s a dmg% bonus on all his damage with higher scaling than Freedom-Sworn’s. The ~40% dmg% bonus Kazuha gets to his basics from EM is pretty much a wash with the atk difference and crit dmg and similarly for the 2nd part of both affixes, except Mistsplitter’s downtime is better than Freedom-Sworns. You do lose some support ability but if you have a C6 Kazuha I don’t think you’re concerned about that.
Kaeya: Since main DPS Kaeya is pretty much Ayaka except he needs Chongyun and has a shorter burst cd that does less damage, this weapon is similarly good on him. You can also use Summit + Diona but then your party composition is wack since it’s those 3 + a hydro so the two are less interchangeable on him. As for just using him as a burst slave, well his burst snapshots so if you have an external infuser then it’ll get the full bonus, so certainly a good weapon on him.
Keqing: Since Keqing has a short burst cd + elemental infusion + she has crit dmg ascension + a crit rate passive so the lower substat value isn’t a problem, she can easily maintain 3 stacks almost all the time. That being said, she can also easily make use of Jade and Summit as well so you’d only be looking at a marginal increase here too.
Qiqi: No. Unless you’re running some nuclear one-shot burst Qiqi for fun, she has all the issues Jean has with this weapon except her elemental damage profile is even worse so there’s even less reason to run it on her.
Xingqiu: There’s 2 main issues with this weapon on Xingqiu. One, his burst doesn’t snapshot so even if you have an external infuser, you’d have to swap in every 5s to maintain that stack on him which if you play Xingqiu you only want to swap onto him once every 2** to use his skill and burst, not to mention one of the stacks is guaranteed to fall off halfway through. Two, his dmg% is more saturated than his atk%, so this weapon’s affix is actually less effective. If you’re running an offensive weapon on Xingqiu, then you’re most likely running Emblem with an ER sands, so between that, his A2, and his cup he’ll be saturated with dmg% and missing attack. You’re better off running Jade as an offensive weapon, especially since it has the added benefit of increasing his healing support ability.
MC: Electro MC is a character who sacks all his damage to be support, so it’s not good on him aside from the fact he doesn’t have infusion and he has a 20s burst. The other 2 MC’s do focus more on damage and have shorter bursts but still have the issue of no natural infusion and nothing else making this weapon better or the two other 2 5* offensive weapons worse on them, so there’s frankly little point to run it over one of those.
Verdict: Generally pretty good as far as 5* offensive weapons go in terms of elemental damage dealers, albeit more conditionally difficult to use compared to the other options. If you still need an elemental damage weapon, then this is a good pull. If you already have that need met by other weapons, well it will still give an upgrade in many cases but you’re going to have to decide if the increase (~5-10%) is going to be worth the number of pulls you might need to sink in.
Thundering Pulse

I’m assuming it doubles to 40% atk% and 80% normal attack dmg% since that’s normally how weapon scaling goes, if it’s not I’ll update this after it comes out
Aside from Elegy which is a support weapon, it’s relatively comparable to both of the other bows. It’s similarly a stat-stick to Skyward Harp in that both have a general offense stat first affix with a second affix that can’t be used off-field. Pulse is strictly speaking numerically superior since 20% atk% = 30% crit dmg from artifacts, but harp has an easier time balancing out stats. It’s also similar to Amos on the normal attack amplification, since it’s 20% atk% + 40% normal attack dmg% vs. 52%normal attack dmg%. Pulse is more conditional but easier to use if those conditions are set since there’s no travel time requirement.
For specific character users:
Amber: If you’re using Amber it’d probably be if she’s C6 with Elegy + Noble praying that her burst doesn’t troll you with targeting and actually procs it. As a main DPS, I’m not sure how she’s played across that weird charge attack cancel, fully charged aim shots, and setting up nuclear explosions with baron bunny but I do know she doesn’t just sit there and left click so either of the other offensive bows is going to work better.
Diona: She’s a support so she uses Elegy. And even if you were playing her main DPS, that’s C4 charged attack spam so you’d use Amos since this doesn’t help.
Fischl: If you’re playing Fischl as a main DPS, then this weapon is great. The weapon’s a good stat-stick regardless and since resummoning Oz should count as elemental skill cast since that’s how it works for Windblume Ode, she should easily be able to maintain 3 stacks. If you’re playing her as a support this weapon is still a good stat-stick, though it lacks the support ability of Elegy so you’re going to have to decide between the two.
Ganyu: Uses charged attacks only so no. If you’re using her burst for a Morgana composition though it’s either this or Harp as the stat-stick and since there you freeze and use Blizzard Strayer the higher crit dmg from this weapon probably comes out on top.
Tartaglia: If you’re going for nuclear one-shots, well technically you don’t need crit so this weapon’s a better stat-stick to reset. If you’re using his melee stance, well even if you do use charged attacks you’ll still have to use your first normal attack at least and the damage increase is more meaningful than that physical damage proc from Harp, albeit the two of them still don’t differ all that much.
Venti: As support he just runs Elegy since that gives him support ability and he does more damage that way unless you’re insanely geared or fighting single enemies. If you’re playing him as a main DPS he goes point blank shotgun with his C1 so you can’t use the 2nd part of the affix, though the difference between this and Harp will again not be too meaningful.
Yoimiya: Well obviously the signature weapon made for her is going to be the best on her. Pretty much all of her damage is on her normals so it’s either this or Amos on her. Amos is much more difficult to use since you’ll have to maintain distance on her but not too much since her targeting range is shorter than her attack range and is a tad bit weaker. Just save yourself the headache and use this over it.
Verdict: If you want a stat-stick bow, then this is one to get over Harp since it can double as a stat-stick and work on auto-attack based characters at the same time. If you already have Harp and only want a stat-stick then there’s not much of a point since they don’t differ by much on that end. Alternatively, if you play an auto-attacking character and have Amos, then this bow is easier to use and slightly stronger if you can maintain all 3 stacks, focus on the easier to use since you don’t have to space your autos so it might be worthwhile to pull just for that reason. Just like Mistsplitter though, if you already have the other weapons your damage will only increase marginally (~5-10%), so again decide if that’s worth the investment.
I'll add the link to the 4* craftable weapons here once I finish writing that when I'm less busy with writing my actual work essays.
For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.


