I’ve written so many of these at this point due to coercion by miHoYo that I might need to think about putting them under a new article series. What the heck starts with F that I can chain off of Fontaine tho?
Anyways, let’s start with the two weapons on the current banner.
Polar Star
You know what Polar Star reminds me of? Polar Express. And what was the Polar Express? A train. You know what else has a train? Honkai Star Rail.

In other words, Genshin is just Honkai 4 checkmate miHoYo.
Ahem, anyways getting off topic.

Scales to 24% and 20/40/60/96% at R5
Polar Star is an offensive weapon, which means the comparison is with every other 5* bow except Elegy. However, instead of having a stronger focused offensive portion and a weaker stat-stick portion, it’s literally a giant stat-stick with some focus on elemental skill/burst. This is opposed to Harp (other offensive portion is a meme in most situations), Pulse (focus is on normal attack with a weaker stat-stick portion), and Amos (literally no stat-stick portion only a focused charged attack portion).
Also, while the atk% portion of Star reads conditional stat-stick, 2 stacks might as well be unconditional. After all, it literally only requires you to hit an enemy and the buff is to atk% which boosts everything, not just a specific part of your damage. Hitting an enemy with normal and charged attack every 12s takes up very little time (nowhere does it say fully charged charged-attack) and isn’t exactly the hardest mechanically to pull off. With 2 stacks, the atk% portion of Star technically already outscales Harp’s cdmg% (1.5atk%=2.0cdmg% roughly) and is equivalent to Pulse’s, especially if the character is only using skill/burst since Harp’s damage proc portion doesn’t work off-field, so in most cases unless you really can’t press 3 buttons and do basic aiming every 12s, Star’s just a better stat-stick than Harp. That being said, the 4th stack of Star’s atk% portion is worth almost twice as much as each of the first 3 stacks, so if you can’t maintain 4 stacks you’ll have a comparatively larger damage loss.
As for comparisons with Pulse/Amos, well first you need to understand that dmg% and atk% are literally equivalent in their increase to damage and scaling method. The reason dmg% is valued more typically is simply because there’s fewer sources of dmg% (b/c there’s more atk buffs and the existence of the feather giving flat atk) and thus it’ll suffer less diminishing returns from stat dilution. Taking that into account, at max stack operation between the three weapons, Star is obviously better for skill/burst focus since neither of the other weapons amplify that. On the other hand, Amos/Pulse have higher values for increasing charged/normal dmg% than Star, so if your focus is on those they’re better. Give or take something like if ~75% of your damage comes from normal/charged attacks then their amplification is more effective.
As for character specific users:
Aloy: If you’re dead set on running her a main DPS with her E, then her focus is on normal attacks and in that case there isn’t really a reason to run Star over Pulse. If you’re just running her as an EQ support, then you wouldn’t even run Elegy since that’s a hassle to stack you’d just run a 4* Sacrificial. If you truly want to do damage on her while using her as an EQ bot, then yes you can run Star but she can’t even readily maintain 3 stacks with 100% uptime, since her E is a 20s cd with 0 guarantee outside of the initial hit and her Q is a single hit burst with 12s cd so if you cast it off cd you can barely scrape 100% uptime on that stack. Not to mention Aloy really doesn’t do enough damage to justify sacking half of her particle generation by replacing Sacrificial with Star.
Amber: If you’re running her as support, then ideally you’d somehow have her at C6 then run her with Elegy + Noble using her burst to proc all 3 of those buffs. If you’re running her as a main DPS, well technically you can maintain 100% uptime on all 4 stacks if you have C4 and you’re a timing god on triggering the puppet explosions. I’m not sure whether charged aimed shots or auto-R cancel is stronger, but regardless if you use your E/Q with 100% uptime they actually make up a meaningful proportion of her damage profile… if your Q hits don’t troll you. Regardless, the difference between Amos/Harp/Star wouldn’t be anything meaningful, but Star’s the most flexible for use elsewhere.
Diona: If you’re using Diona as a support then yeah you’d use Elegy with her C6 to set up a massive EM boost. That being said, everyone knows the real way to play Diona is obviously ofc C4 charged attack spam and if you’re doing that of course the best weapon is… probably Star actually because you’re forced to stand in that circle which means you can’t kite to get Amos damage bonus maxed out and since you can’t kite, the enemies are probably also sitting in that circle which means her burst is hitting them which means easy 100% 4-stack uptime.
Fischl: Since Fischl is almost always used as an Oz bot, if you’re aiming for damage then you’d 100% use Star, since aside from boosting Oz’s damage with the 1st part of the affix, you can always have 4 stacks of Star on Oz since he snapshots and you can resummon him to update the snapshot after you’ve hit with your EQ. If you’re going for more support ofc you run Elegy.
Ganyu: If you’re going charged shot melt, then you don’t actually use your burst nor try to actually connect with your E because they will consume the pyro you need to melt the bloom which does the most damage, and thus you’re only ever going to get 2 stacks and Amos will be better. If you’re just using her EQ, then Star is the best for damage (Elegy better for support ofc) since you have 100% 4-stack uptime. You do have to be careful about your crit rate though, because between Blizzard + 2 Cryo+ base + Star, that’s over 93% crit rate already so 2-3 crit substats or any other crit buff and you’re over cap.
Kujou Sara: Star would be compared to Harp here, because using Elegy on her is awkward af and she neither normal nor charged attacks enough for Amos/Pulse. Harp does have higher base attack so a larger attack buff, but Star’s affix just gives her more offensive stats for damage even if atk% is diluted and she can only maintain 3 stacks with 100% uptime due to 20s Q cd. And she has to use charged attacks in her awkward rotation already anyways. Frankly the difference isn’t the end of the world, but Harp for more atk% support and Star for more damage from Sara.
Tartaglia: You know, this weapon is supposed to be Childe’s signature weapon but he’s not even the best user for it and this is doubly true if he’s not C6. If Childe isn’t C6, then he is almost always using his burst in ranged form. One because energy costs, two because it eats up time in melee stance and thus increases his cd, and three because once Childe is in melee form, he’s providing the hydro as a base for others to react off of, not vaporizing himself. Putting aside the fact that Childe’s E is some kind of stupid convoluted piecewise function, all you need to be aware of is if you spend more than 7s in his melee form, then your cd of melee stance is more than 12s. That means you cannot retain your stacks from melee stance to your next burst if you spend more than 7s in it. Thus, if you don’t want a literal 0 stack burst (which is probably half of your damage if not more at C0), you’ll have to normal +charged in ranged stance before using it. If you want a third stack, then you’ll also have to hit enemy with the E swap damage while they have pyro on them, then get them hit by pyro as soon as possible then burst. Otherwise you can spend an eternity twiddling your thumbs waiting for the hydro applied by Childe to clear so you can vaporize your burst and regardless that’s 15 extra energy cost. It’s not as problematic when you have C6 since you can swap back to melee stance within 12s, but either way you can only get 3 stacks for your burst and you can only maintain 4 stacks for 12s in melee stance at most. Yeah, it’s still the best option for damage on him (Pulse locks him out of using charged attacks and less amplification on burst), but it’s going to be mendoukusai at C0 and if you’re getting a 0-stack burst there’s really no point of using Star over Harp/Pulse.
Venti: If you’re fighting multiple enemies, you gotta be a next level leviathan if you want to out damage swirl with traditional scaling and while you can theoretically reach that with Star, please for the love of god just save your money. If you’re fighting a single enemy, well I don’t know why you’d be using Venti since they’d probably just walk out of your burst, but if you are Star is by far the best for him since just like Ganyu he can easily maintain 100% uptime on 4-stacks and is EQ focused.
Yoimiya: Hello, your E literally does not exist in the dealing direct damage department which means you actually can only ever get 3 stacks, and your Q might as well not exist both in the damage department and the energy drain to have it running if you’re also using Shimenawa. Also you literally only pretty much normal attack on her which is also almost all her damage so just use the signature weapon designed for her Pulse thanks.
Verdict: Functionally speaking, Star is the best general stat-stick bow now (since it’s condition might as well be unconditional), not to mention it’s applicable to more characters since in a typical party there are 3 EQ focused characters who are predominantly off-field compared to 1 who is on-field that may or may not be normal/charged attack focused. If you want a single general use, one size fits all, damage oriented bow, then Star is the best option and it’s the best damage option on characters with a lack of focus. If the character is highly focused on normal/charged attacks though, then there are better options.
Akuoumaru

Scales to 0.24% and 80%
You might as well think of this weapon as Raiden Shogun the claymore, because not only is it burst focused, its efficacy is also highly dependent on the rest of your party members, just like Raiden Shogun is. Assuming the equipped character has an 80-cost burst and the other three party members are Raiden Shogun + 2 80-cost bursts, the damage bonus you’d get is 79.2%. In the worst case scenario with 4 40-cost bursts, you’ll still get 38.4% burst dmg%. Regardless, it’s a burst focused offensive weapon. As for comparative purposes, it’s almost always better than both Sea Lord and Archaic, which makes sense since it’s gacha and those two are free. Outside of that, it’s weird to compare since no other 4*’s are both specifically burst and offense focused.
Probably the most general and useful comparison would be with Serpent Spine. Spine has a better substat for ideal offensive stat distribution and in all likelihood is easier to get to R5 than Akuoumaru, which is doubly important since Spine scales worse with refinements than Akuoumaru does so lower refinement comparisons will be even worse for it. Akuoumaru’s dmg% is unconditional compared to Spine’s, though generally if you’re getting hit often enough that you can’t maintain Spine’s stacks you have bigger issues to worry about anyways (outside of things like DoT situations). In the most ideal situation (330 total team burst energy cost) for Akuoumaru, ~63% of a character’s damage profile has to come from their burst for the affix to outscale Spine. The required percentages increase as total team energy decreases, until at ~208 total team energy 100% of a character’s damage profile needs to be from their burst to outscale. In other words, even if the team as a whole has average energy cost (60 each for 240 total for 57.6% burst dmg% requiring ~87% damage profile from burst), Akuoumaru will be hard pressed to be stronger than Spine. Thus, it requires both high team energy and high burst dependence, which is difficult to evaluate generally.
For specific character users:
Beidou: In the maximum optimal situation (15 burst discharges with C2 only bouncing between 2 enemies so her E gets the least mileage on AoE damage with 100% uptime), then her burst makes up ~75% of her damage profile so yeah ‘Maru could be better than Spine. You better also have good substats to have a working crit stat distribution and team members with high energy costs (Raiden can’t use Beidou burst effectively so you’re missing out on that 90 cost) to make it work though, so good luck with that.
Chongyun: Burst is the largest proportion of his damage, but his E actually makes up close to a third of his damage profile if both parts hit, not to mention due to being a 40 cost himself he already sacks a lot of the passive, so yeah unless you’re setting up some melt nuke with 80 cost team members, ‘Maru’s weaker.
Diluc: Burst is literally used to just get pyro enchant in most cases and does peanut damage in most cases and is also a 40 cost, so you can scratch it right now.
Eula: Eula seems like the perfect candidate for this weapon; burst focus, uses Raiden, 80-cost herself. Problem is, if you’re C0, the attacks you do to stack up the burst actually make up a large portion of your damage. Not to mention you’re super dmg% diluted from all the different sources and if you don’t crit on your burst you’re literally doomed. Eula has the reverse issue of Beidou; Beidou’s discharge amount is fixed but her E has AoE and can hit multiple enemies to make up a larger portion of her damage distribution. Eula’s stacking can pretty much only hit one enemy but her burst explosion is AoE and can hit multiple. If you hit 3+ enemies and the damage isn’t overkill, then ‘Maru’s better; but if you’re just fighting a single enemy at C0 then your overall damage is going to be higher with Spine.
Noelle: The only thing burst dmg% increases is that single initial hit, so no.
Razor: Same issue as Noelle.
Sayu: This weapon’s actually an interesting choice for Sayu. Given that Sayu needs both EM and atk%, unless you’re a giga-whale you pretty much eschew your crit stats so the substat comparison isn’t particularly a problem. And her burst (80-cost) is the part of her kit that does the most damage, and her healing scales on atk% as well. So unless you’re planning on running an ER weapon, ‘Maru’s likely going to be your best choice for offensive weapons. That being said, for most players I doubt whether your healer doing more damage is of particularly important concern when you’re not relying on Sayu to give you massive damage in the first place.
Xinyan: If you’re using Xinyan as a main DPS and thus using her charged attacks, Spine and even Whiteblind’s going to better for damage due to her damage distribution. On the other hand, if you’re simply using her as an EQ bot then it’s more complicated. With C2 the physical portion of Xinyan’s burst is guaranteed to crit so Spine’s substat is entirely wasted, but Xinyan’s pyro portion will actually out damage her physical portion if her shield holds up through the DoT so she will actually still need crit. Not to mention the proportion of her damage profile coming from her burst is also dependent on whether her shield holds up, since it can be anything from over 75% to only around 60%. Not to mention her burst is only 60 energy. Thus, unless you can’t maintain her shield and the rest of the party is high cost, Spine will outperform ‘Maru.
Verdict: Are there situations where Akuoumaru will outperform existing weapons? Yes. Are they worth fishing in the weapon banner specifically to get multiple copies? I highly recommend against it. The situations where there will be a meaningful difference are pretty restricted, not to mention they require high refinements otherwise Spine will perform pretty much the same if not better. And Spine is much easier to get than Akuoumaru is.
Now then, time to wait to see if the other two weapons in the 4* series follow the same pattern like Favonius (literal same affix) or like the Inazuma crafted weapons (same focus but different effects).
For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.


