Yeah they’re all pretty much exactly the same except the base attack (the literal 3% atk% substat on Wavebreaker as tradeoff for being type 45 rip), so the same considerations apply.
Mouun’s Moon

Scales to 0.24% and 80%
Same breakdown as Akuoumaru needing high energy cost for team members and high distribution of damage in burst. Bow’s don’t have a Serpent Spine though, but as far as other things with dmg% goes the best to compare it to are Alley Hunter and Stringless. Alley has the same stats, but its affix really only works on burst and skill due to the 4s on-field restriction. Stringless gives slightly more damage to burst and skill than Alley but has a more restrictive substat. Both of them are lower than Spine, getting outscaled at ~167 and 200 energy respectively, though this value is constant across refinements rather than decreasing with refinements as Spine does. Same guidelines apply here; if total team energy is high and a large proportion of damage comes from burst, then Moon is better (at 330 party energy, ~50/60% of damage profile from burst to outscale Alley/Stringless). Otherwise, either Alley/Stringless will be better depending on whether you can use EM.
For specific character users:
Aloy: I wouldn’t use any of them on her over Sacrificial as a battery, but if you’re going for damage while using her as an EQ bot, well if all her E bombs hit then the split is roughly 40/60 for E vs. Q in terms of damage, not to mention she can melt her burst and it’s 40 cost. No particular reason to use Moon over Stringless.
Amber: I also wouldn’t use any of them on her over a support bow, but as an EQ bot her burst does have a larger portion of damage than Aloy. That is if all the waves of arrows hit which they typically troll and don’t, not to mention her burst is also 40 cost so not particularly a reason to use Moon over Alley.
Diona: Are you really going to make me meme about Diona for damage twice in the same article? Fine, after you’re done playing her C4 charged attack, if you’re playing her for EQ damage, her E vs. Q distribution is also about 40/60, but she can’t melt easily and her Q is 80 cost, so yeah not really much difference. You also should just use Sacrificial out of the 4*’s like a normally functioning human being.
Fischl: Most of Fischl’s damage is from Oz as an elemental skill over time, and even her Q is mostly just to reset Oz rather than using it for inherent damage. She also gets very poor mileage out of EM, so Alley is the best of the three on her.
Ganyu: If you’re using her as an EQ bot, the vast, extremely vast majority of her damage comes from her burst and she scales super poorly with EM. As long as the other three members of the party have average cost burst (60) as well, Moon is the strongest.
Kujou Sara: Both Alley and Moon have 44 base attack, which is the most important part for her atk% buff. Outside of that, unless you can actually hit the stormclusters (which is almost never against most enemies since they aren’t super big), it’s around 50/50 between her burst and the rest of her damage so Alley would come out on top in most cases.
Tartaglia: If you’re not using him as a DPS, then you’re only using him as a Q bot. In that case, all of your damage is from your burst and whether Moon is better than Stringless is then dependent on the rest of your team energy; if they’re at least average Moon wins out otherwise Stringless does.
Venti: If you’re running Venti, then you’re normally fighting multiple enemies in which case Stringless is better due to EM scaling better than atk%. If for some reason you’re fighting 1 enemy and still running Venti, then Moon’s going to be better than Alley as long as you have sufficient team energy.
Yoimiya: Her elemental skill literally doesn’t do direct damage and her burst might as well not, you best not attempt any of these.
Verdict: Same issues as Akuoumaru, though Moon has generally weaker competitors compared to Spine so the threshold is lower and thus there are more situations where it’ll outperform existing options. I still don’t recommend gunning specifically for it since the benefits are relatively marginal, especially if your existing Alley/Stringless happens to be high refine so you’ll need multiple copies of Moon too.
Wavebreaker’s Fin

Scales to 0.24% and 80%
Same thing as the other two on team composition and damage distribution. This one is the biggest headache to compare to, one because of its abnormal base attack and two because there aren’t any polearms that are strikingly similar. The Catch is one comparison; if you convert the burst crit to dmg% at a 1:1.5 ratio based on artifact stats, then it’s equivalent to 50% burst dmg%. The difference is you can’t exactly just swap to an ER hourglass if you need ER on Wavebreaker as an offset comparison in all cases because then the only atk% you’ll have is the 13.8% from Wavebreaker, meaning if you have no other sources of atk% the high base attack is wasted. You can also compare to Deathmatch as a general offensive weapon but they’re also entirely on opposite sides of the spectrum in terms of base attack. You can probably just assume the crit substat being better while the atk affix being worse washes out to the equivalent of 48% dmg% generally. Regardless, you’ll still need a more concentrated burst damage profile and high energy cost on team.
For specific character users:
Hu Tao: Definitely not burst focused, so wouldn’t use it compared to other weapons. Even if you plan to solely use her as a Q nuke bot, because Hu Tao’s attack comes from her HP and not her base attack, high base attack weapons aren’t actually helpful since she normally doesn’t cap and something like Dragon’s Bane would be better there for the larger substat value.
Raiden Shogun: Well, it’s workable on Raiden if you have a high energy team but you’ll almost definitely need an ER sands if you have a high energy team and because you’ll otherwise be on the lower end without an ER weapon just from her ascension and Emblem. That’ll leave you diluted from dmg% from A2/Wavebreaker/Emblem and rougher on atk% even if you use an atk% cup. Catch is more flexible in that regard and it gives her crit for better distribution and you can get R5 for free, so there’s really no need to get this over it for her.
Rosaria: Rosaria is relatively heavily indexed into burst with something close around a 70/30 ratio for Q/E, but if all you plan to do is use Rosaria as a burst bot for support she needs crit, and this weapon doesn’t give crit. Deathmatch gives a lot of crit without any meaningful damage falloff (if any depending on team energy), so just use that for more support.
Thoma: Thoma is also super heavily indexed into burst and has an 80 cost, but his burst isn’t particularly high damage and its main focus is on shielding. Having it up all the time is the most important thing so you’ll actually need ER and same issue with atk% sourcing. Damage difference wouldn’t be too meaningful and Catch is free so just run that.
Xiangling: Xiangling’s burst is actually about doing damage and she’s also heavily indexed into burst with an 80 cost. However, Xiangling does need a good bit of ER even if she has someone like Bennett to battery her, and if you run her with Bennett high base attack is less relevant as he just tacks on a flat amount either way. If you do have a high energy team, Wavebreaker can come out ahead in terms of damage but you could also just use multiple free weapons that add offense and help with energy in Catch and Kitain even.
Xiao: Repeat after me, miHoYo absolutely hates Xiao to the end of oblivion.
Zhongli: Low cost burst and isn’t focused on burst damage and has difficulty charging his burst without ER. If your Zhongli is stacked to the point of worrying about doing damage, you’ll be using 5* weapons and not this at that point.
Verdict: There are a lot of burst damage profiled polearm characters, but they all need ER to charge their burst which means you’ll need to be very invested to have proper stat set up. Not to mention the same issue of also needing your team to be higher energy and the fact that a weapon that’s burst damage focused but has ER in Catch exists as a free weapon which limits the actual benefits Wavebreaker would add. I feel like a broken record at this point but the benefits are unlikely to outweigh the costs.
In general, I wouldn’t gun specifically for any of the new 4* series unless you also want the 5* weapons on the banner. They’re pretty specific and have relatively restrictive set-up requirements in team energy cost. Not to mention they’ll most likely need higher refinement level to actually outperform some of the other options lying around which are likely to already be higher refinement level.
For other weapon analysis, go to Fontaine's Furnace™.


